So listen to a professional who has thought of that and much, much more?
Thereās quite a few 531 2 days a week programmes. In some of them squat and bench are paired one day and ohp with deadlift on another.
Thereās also another version with two days in the gym and other days doing bodyweight work. Thereās a couple of free examples on this site.
Well practicing the lift once a week seems much more reasonable than once every two weeks⦠So thank you ![]()
Barbell work 2x a week is suboptimal for a beginner.
This would be ideal:
You can do the 2x a week and then throw in some quick bodyweight sessions throughout the day. Itās not ideal and I wouldnāt do this, but itās a workaround.
While I think school and studying are important, I think āother hobbiesā are an excuse to not train. Piano doesnāt take that long, and he could always put that on the back burner temporarily to focus on school and training, especially if heās not doing a music program.
Iām no ānazi-gym ratā, but I lifted and trained/fought Muay Thai through undergrad, and lifted through grad school. I know exactly how it is to balance training and education, and itās not difficult given that heās actually interested in it.
What if piano is a higher priority to him than his lifting hobby?
Then maybe he should focus on piano instead of lifting.
Thereās a lot of stuff Iād like to take up/learn that could add value to my life, but only so many hours to do so.
Me too, especially with kids around. I guess my point was that heās already decided how many hours he can budget himself for lifting and the only decision left is how to make the most of it.
I guess my point is that in taking up something new thst often requires 3-4x a week frequency, it might be a good idea to table other items until hes developed the skills to get a better return at 2x a week
If he had even a year of experience, I think the 2x a week 5/3/1 rest pause would be a great program
Iāve eyed that one up a few times as well. Looks like āfunā
I did it after doing the BBB challenge twice, back when I just started taking lifting seriously. It jacked me up and I didnāt get a good return from it at the time
This would be my go to if I ever got too busy to train 3-4x a week.
Sure lifting 2x per week isnāt perfect, but you can still make progress. Itās not like 3-4x per week is absolutely essential.
Since this kid in question will be extremely technically limited on everything, that just gives him an excuse to go and use machines a bit more.
Most of the people I train (including kids) will be 2x a week, doing something like the following.
āPhase 1ā
This is for people who are very uncoordinated. This is done every session.
- Goblet Squats: 1-2 hard sets of 8-12 (2-3 warm ups)
- Barbell Bench variation: as above
- Smith Machine Good Morning or KB Deadlift: as above
- Chest-Supported Row: as above
Once theyāve met arbitrary standards for coordination and strength
Day 1:
- Barbell squat variation: up to 2-3 clusters of 2+2+2
- Incline or CG Bench Press (or OHP): as above
3.1. SM Good Morning or KB Deadlift: 3 x 8-12
3.2. DB Push variation: 3 x 8-12
3.3. Lat Pulldown or Row variation: 3 x 8-12 - Whatever the client wants to do
Day 2:
- Deadlift variation: up to 2-3 clusters of 2+2+2
- Bench press variation: as above
3.1. Goblet Squat: 3 x 8-12
3.2. DB Push variation: 3 x 8-12
3.3. Lat Pulldown or Row variation: 3 x 8-12 - Whatever the client wants to do
Simple
After that wears out theyāll be decently proficient at SBD, have some strength and hopefully some muscle. The rep ranges for the clusters are flexible, but i like using them because they give thewhatever a ton of high-quality reps at significant loads
Twice a week training has a long and established history. Stuart McRobert has written pretty extensively on the topic.
For the beginner you could just swop out the rest pause in the ohp and bench for 1x or 5x5 FSL in that programme.
Edit - thatās meant to be for the 531 rest pause programme linked above.
I think thatās a good approach. Still less than ideal compared to doing it 3-4x, but effective.
As a beginner, I started with three workouts a week, an hour each. As I know, it is important to work for more than one muscle group, to do different exercises in different workouts. I started with strengthening my back.