Thought for the day:
I usually don’t write up critiques on an officer’s actions or decisions, mainly, because I have been in situations where a split second decision has to be made and the results are securitized for months. My thinking is basically, “I wasn’t on scene, so, I don’t really know what happened’. I feel like we all can learn from analyzing tactical situations and decisions. I truly hope the officer recovers, both physically and mentally from her violent attack. There are lessons to be learned here for all of us. I have watched this video several times and frankly I am stunned at the complacency and total lack of situational awareness.
“There is very little evidence that what this community teaches for defensive tactics works with any regularity during violent resistance or a sudden violent assault.” Toney Bauer.
Surveillance video shows the female officer, who is of Asian descent, approach Gerardo Contreras on Friday and tell him to turn around and put his hands on his head.
“ put your hands on your head” I thought this method of handcuffing went out with the revolver. It is an extremely awkward and dangerous position to cuff from, especially if the officer is shorter than the suspect. It allows for offensive strikes to be thrown from a high position and does not allow adequate time for the officer to gain distance. It also is the slowest method I know.
The 33-year-old turns around, but while the officer puts on plastic gloves before patting him down, he turns back to face her, shoves her, then wrestles with her on the ground.
I simply don’t understand this. If you think you need gloves to arrest, have them on before you approach the suspect. The worst thing you can do, especially with a mental patient or anyone for that matter, is give them time to think about being arrested. Put those cuffs on as fast as possible. I have seen officers screw around after telling someone they are under arrest and the suspect starts building up anger and fear and then the fight is on.
You are carrying a non-lethal shotgun with a sling, obviously you had some prior knowledge the suspect was a mental case, why in hell did you not keep you distance until backup arrived? You had the means to keep your distance and still protect yourself and the public. I have used non-lethal rounds on suspects and they work about 9 out of 10 times. Slinging your shotgun over your shoulder just gave him the advantage, especially after you were slammed to the ground. Weapons with slings are hard enough to fight around when you are rolling on the ground.
The video first made public by the San Francisco Police Officers Association shows four men rushing to help, hitting Contreras and trying to pull him off the officer as he punches her in the head and face. Shortly afterward, other officers arrived and arrested Contreras, who is apparently homeless with mental health issues and a record of prior arrests.
IMO, if the citizens had not intervened on the officer’s behalf, he would have killed the officer, especially if he had a weapon. All he needed was an ink pen to stab you 50 times in the throat. I have no knowledge of the officer’s grappling skills or even she had any, but, if appears you are giving up at 75 to 100 pounds to your attacker. That is hard to overcome for anyone, especially after getting slammed to the pavement. Hard surfaces plays no favorites when it comes to injuries.
The officer, who has worked for the department for five years, suffered bumps and bruises, Tony Montoya, president of the San Francisco Police Officers Association, told the San Francisco Chronicle.
I know it states the officer is a five year veteran of the force, but, I have my doubts the officer has spent five years working the street. I have known many officers who have spent years working admin assignments and probably the last violent encounter they had was in field training. I know the SFPD has been hit hard with experienced officers leaving one of the epicenters of wokeness. I know the department is working with a shortage, one of the reasons the officer was working solo. If the department is going to pull admin officers to help the rank and file, at least they should offer some type of defensive tactics / situational awareness training before tossing officers to the wolves.
But, that training has to be realistic with simple, direct defensive tactics that have shown to work. I am very glad she survived.