[quote]Professor X wrote:
[quote]Majin wrote:
I’m all for promoting discipline and dedication that produces real transformations in people’s bodies. But I’d much rather show newbs how to measure what they eat, so that they know where they’re at and add more food as necessary. [/quote]
Measure their food?
I am all for counting macro nutrients as a newb and calories. I don’t think I have ever written otherwise. What I am against is this extreme minimalist approach in all cases. Telling newbs that no one can gain more than 2lbs of muscle in a month is fairly common here…when it is not true.
This can affect how someone “measures” their food. They start focusing more on the calculations than making sure their lifts are going up and their shirts fit tighter in the arms and chest. I truly think most beginners need to AVOID getting too precise and most damn sure don’t need to be micro-analyzing their food intake beyond those broad strokes.
Yes, count calories.
Yes, get a good idea in general of carb intake and even tolerance…but the truth is, it takes TIME before you bring out the microscope.
I see a lot of really small guys with calculators. They can explain the shit out of their food intake…and quote what the latest author has to say by heart.
They miss that that heart in the gym and the kitchen counts way more.
That is all I am discussing…take it or leave it.[/quote]
So I mention counting calories and macros, and now that’s nitpicking and microscopes to you? Meanwhile, you say you’re against a minimalist approaches, when that’s what the 6-meals rule is… great logic.
I don’t see how “6 meals a day + making sure your lifts go up” is better than “count calories and macros + making sure your lifts go up”. Just the opposite. I’d rather count everything at home and then eat whenever I like than shove meals down my throat by a random schedule pulled out of someone’s ass.
No it’s not what you’re discussing. You made a thread about frequent eating, called it such, said newbies NEED to learn to eat by the clock and made a whole series of intro posts on it. For discussion of “Lifestyle”, create a proper thread and describe the topic. Instead of saying one thing and then derailing it.