[quote]roybot wrote:
[quote]challer1 wrote:
[quote]Schwarzfahrer wrote:
Seen it.
It’s decent if you’re a genre-fan. Some of the effects and fights are great.
The
spoiler
dwarfish underground chase
spoilerend
is amazingly done, in a shorter film with less fights it would have been even more impressive.
If you’re not a diehard fantasy geek, prepare to be bored.
It takes no genius to figure out why.
Partitioning a smallish book first into two, then three parts was motivated by money alone, not artistic integrity.
The Huffington Post nerd can go suck an intellectual orifice of choice, his argument is baffling at best.
It doesn’t matter what Tolkien in his nightly nerdogasms envisioned later on, in order to make his creation appear more solid and whole.
If we find Grimm’s lost annotations to “Red Riding Hood”, and they lay out a wolfish genealogy, explaining at great lengths why this particular predator could talk along with establishing the history of the “Hunters Guild” and other outrageously geeky stuff, a three part movie about a little girl visiting her grandma would still.
Suck.
Ass.
A lot.
It’s painfully obvious that a movie is bloated when it takes ~40 minutes to get the hobbit’s furry ass out of Hobbit Town and 20+ minutes for Bilbo and Gollum to sort things out.
Let’s hear it from the director and former director:
“one of the drawbacks of The Hobbit is it’s relatively lightweight compared to LOTR” (Jackson)
and
“The Hobbit is better contained in a single film and kept brisk and fluid with no artificial 'break point” (delTorro)
[/quote]
Agree 1000x. It’s not like it was an unpleasant film to watch, but when I go to see a movie, I expect the basic elements of a story to be present - intro, rising action, climax, descending action, and a meaningful resolution.
The way the movie ended to me was the worst part. You might expect a TV show to end like that (with a new episode coming the next week) but going to pay for a movie like that and have it end suddenly with no resolution and a year to the next film makes me feel like I’ve been ripped off.[/quote]
Watch Prometheus. Then you’ll know what it’s really like to sit through a movie with no ending. [/quote]
Just for you my friend