[quote]countingbeans wrote:
Testy1 wrote:
countingbeans wrote:
Testy1 wrote:
countingbeans wrote:
Testy1 wrote:
I don’t believe he was saying don’t go back to school, just don’t go straight from undergrad to grad school.
As far as employment history, if you can’t factor in that thousands of people were losing their jobs during a period when someone wasn’t “chasing the dream”, then you most likely shouldn’t be in charge of hiring.
There is a significant difference between working in a warehouse and getting your MBA in this job market, and just working in a warehouse.
If you don’t understand that, I know why you aren’t in charge of hiring.
Yeah people are losing/lost their jobs. The ones that are putting in effort to be better in the field with laid off are going to look better than those that are sitting back blaming the economy for their situation.
How is this not common sense?
Again, no one is saying that you shouldn’t be trying to better yourself. It’s doubtful that someone that has taken the initiative to get a degree is going to stagnate in a warehouse.
Maybe that is part of why the economy is in the state it’s in, we have beancounters doing the hiring.
Your reading comprehension is lacking here. You quoted someone who told OP not to get his MBA saying that he “should post more and others should post less.” When neither of you have any fucking clue what you are talking about, given the current job market.
Why do people who don’t do this for a living suddenly think they know how successful businesses run once they log into the internet?
Oh and I’m sure a designer such as yourself could asses a potential employee better.
Who’s reading comprehension is lacking?
This is what he said,
“Getting an MBA just out of college is not the way to go. You will not get nearly as much out of it as you would if you spent five plus years out in the business world. I went back and got my MBA fifteen years after college. There were several fresh college graduates in my program as well. They were smart and eager. They were loaded with conceptual knowledge. What they lacked was experiential knowledge.”
My guess is he has more years experience than you have been out of diapers.
Re-read my posts. I specifically said in THIS JOB MARKET his advice is fucking dumb, if you want to work in finance when the market normalizes.
Christ it’s like talking to my son around here sometimes.
Tell you what, you’re right. He shouldn’t pursue his MBA. Even though he can’t get a job in his field, using his undergrad degree, he should certainly wait until he has worked in finance to get his advanced degree.
And when he goes for and interview in 18 months, and is up against 4 other applicants that DID get their MBA while they couldn’t get a job in this market, I’m sure he’ll get the job before they do. Because, you know, a lot of people were unemployed, what was he to do? Woe is me…[/quote]
Beans, I answered your points directly myself. In case you did not notice I clarified your misunderstanding. But to put it in your words, one of us does do this for a living, and it is not you. If you do not agree with me, so be it. Calling my suggestions “just fucking dumb” when it appears that I am the professional and you are starting out, well I will just chalk it up to hubris.