The Andrew Tate Case

This cracked me up.

4 Likes

You wouldn’t call a king a president.

That’s a poor comparison.

Julius Ceasar was a high-ranking general in a lot of debt when he conquered Gaul. He commanded multiple legions, each with their own general (Legatus) commanding them. There’s nothing misleading or incorrect about calling him a “general”. His level of command during the Gallic Conquests would be equivalent to modern three or four star generals.

What’s misleading is suggesting that he wasn’t a general or that the Roman Republic didn’t have a rank structure in their armies that featured commanders we now call “generals”.

1 Like

image

Maximus Decimus Meridius approves.

1 Like

Exactly. The path to king is different from the path to president.

Note exactly. Caesar held a political office, not simply a military rank.

Meridius.

Dwight Eisenhower was the military governor of American-occupied Germany.

As a general.

David Patraeus performed many political functions while in command.

As a general.

Whatever subject you teach, I hope it isn’t history.

Is there an echo in here?

Shallow

and Pedantic

Was he elected?

Was he elected?

I could teach it as I am very knowledgeable on the subject, far more than you could ever be but you already knew that. It’s sad how I mentioned something as simply being trivia and you felt the need to try and outdo the college educated dude with a library card. Have I hurt you that bad?

It’s a Romance language joke.

Well, yeah. But it’s nothing to cry about.

image

image

1 Like

Gaius Iulius Gaii filius Gaii nepos Caesar Imperator, ab anno 42 a.C.n.Divus Iulius (natus Romae ex stirpe patricia die 13 Iulii 100 a.C.n.; ibidem mortuus 15 Martii 44 a.C.n.), fuit vir publicus, consul, dux exercitus, dictator in perpetuum,[1] orator, poeta, insignis scriptor prosae Latinae. Partes maximi momenti egit in casibus, quibus Res Publica Romana in Imperium Romanum transmutata est. Triumviratu cum Crasso et Pompeio, praestantissimis civibus, constituto ab anno 60 a.C.n. per aliquot annos apud Romanos plurimum valuit, quamvis ei potestatem per rationespopulares accumulanti senatores, qui optimatibus favebant, videlicet Cato Minor, Cicero, et alii, opponebant. Victa Gallia in dictionemque populi Romani redacta, Caesar imperium Romanum ad Oceanum Britannicum et Rhenum extendit, et ipse primus dux Romanus hoc ponte exstructo, illum navibus transgressus est. Ipse pater anni intercalaris Iulianum fecit Calendarium

Gaio Giulio Cesare (in latino: Gaius Iulius Caesar , Pronuncia restaurata o classica; AFI: [ˈɥÀːjʊs ˈjuː.li.ʊs ˈkÉÌŻÉ›ÌŻ.sĂ€:r];[N 2][3] nelle epigrafi C·IVLIVS·C·F·CAESAR e DIVVS IVLIVS;[4] in greco antico: Î“ÎŹÏŠÎżÏ‚ áŒžÎżÏÎ»ÎčÎżÏ‚ ÎšÎ±áż–ÏƒÎ±Ï?, GĂĄĂŻos IĂșlios KaĂźsar ; Roma, 13 luglio 101 a.C.[1] o 12 luglio 100 a.C.[2] – Roma, 15 marzo 44 a.C.) Ăš stato un militare, politico, console, dittatore, pontefice massimo, oratore e scrittore romano, considerato uno dei personaggi piĂč importanti e influenti della storia.[5]

Tras su año consular, CĂ©sar recibiĂł poderes proconsulares para gobernar las provincias de la Galia Transalpina (actualmente el sur de Francia) e Iliria (la costa de Dalmacia) durante cinco años, gracias al apoyo de los otros dos miembros del triunvirato, que cumplieron con la palabra dada. A estas dos provincias se añadiĂł la Galia Cisalpina tras la muerte inesperada de su gobernador, Quinto Cecilio Metelo CĂ©ler. Eran unas provincias muy buenas para alguien que, como CĂ©sar, y siguiendo la tĂ­pica mentalidad del procĂłnsul romano, no tenĂ­a intenciones de gobernar pacĂ­ficamente, pues estaba necesitado de bienes para pagar las fabulosas sumas que adeudaba.66​

La oportunidad se le presentĂł mediante una teĂłrica amenaza de los helvecios, que pensaban emigrar al oeste de las Galias. Decidido a impedirlo y con la excusa polĂ­tica de que se acercarĂ­an demasiado a la provincia de la Galia Cisalpina —los helvecios querĂ­an instalarse en pago SantĂłn, al norte de la Aquitania— reclutĂł tropas e iniciĂł las operaciones bĂ©licas que, a la postre, darĂ­an lugar a lo que mĂĄs tarde se denominĂł guerra de las Galias(58-49 a. C.),67​ en la que conquistĂł la llamada Galia Comata o Galia melenuda (actualmente Francia, PaĂ­ses Bajos, Suiza y partes de BĂ©lgica y Alemania), en varias campañas. CĂ©sar hizo una demostraciĂłn de fuerza construyendo por dos veces un puente sobre el Rin e invadiendo en dos ocasiones Germania sin intenciĂłn de conquistarla, e hizo otro alarde de fortaleza cruzando el canal de la Mancha tambiĂ©n por dos veces hacia las islas BritĂĄnicas, si bien es cierto que estas dos incursiones tenĂ­an un sentido mĂĄs estratĂ©gico que colonial.68​

Entre sus legados (comandantes de legión) se contaban Lucio Julio César, Marco Antonio, Marco Licinio Craso, hijo de su compañero de triunvirato, Tito Labieno, cliente de Pompeyo, y Quinto Tulio Cicerón, el hermano mås joven de Marco Tulio Cicerón, todos hombres que habrían de ser personajes importantes en los años siguientes

CĂ©sar profite de sa popularitĂ© pour prĂ©parer l’étape suivante de sa carriĂšre : normalement, le SĂ©nat prolonge le mandat d’un consul par le proconsulat d’une province pour un an. CĂ©sar contourne cette rĂšgle avec l’aide du tribun de la plĂšbe Publius Vatinius : celui-ci fait voter par le peuple un plĂ©biscite qui confie Ă  CĂ©sar et pour cinq ans deux provinces, la Gaule cisalpine et l’Illyrie, avec le commandement de trois lĂ©gions (lex Vatinia ). Pour sauver une apparence d’autoritĂ©, le SĂ©nat lui accorde en plus la Gaule transalpine et une quatriĂšme lĂ©gionA 36.

Homme politique averti, CĂ©sar peut attaquer CicĂ©ron de façon frontale. Ce dernier, privĂ© de ses biens, choisit de s’exiler. CĂ©sar n’a alors plus d’ennemis notables Ă  Rome17.

DĂšs la fin de son consulat, CĂ©sar gagne rapidement la Gaule, tandis que le prĂ©teur Lucius Domitius Ahenobarbus et le tribun de la plĂšbe Antistius le citent en justice pour rĂ©pondre Ă  l’accusation d’illĂ©galitĂ©s commises pendant son mandat. En fin juriste, CĂ©sar fait objecter par les autres tribuns qu’il ne peut ĂȘtre citĂ© en application de la loi MemmiaN 8, qui interdit toute poursuite contre un citoyen absent de Rome pour le service de la RĂ©publique. Pour Ă©viter toute autre mise en cause devant la justice, CĂ©sar s’appliqua durant son proconsulat Ă  demeurer dans ses provinces. Il passe ainsi chaque hiver en Gaule cisalpine, oĂč il reçoit partisans, clients et solliciteurs et s’assure chaque annĂ©e d’avoir parmi les Ă©lus Ă  Rome des magistrats qui lui soient favorablesA 37. La gestion de ses affaires Ă  Rome mĂȘme est confiĂ©e Ă  son secrĂ©taire Lucius Cornelius Balbus, un chevalier d’origine espagnole, avec qui il Ă©change par prĂ©caution des courriers chiffrĂ©sA 38.

DĂšs le dĂ©but de son proconsulat, CĂ©sar engage la conquĂȘte de la Gaule en usant du prĂ©texte de la migration des HelvĂštes en mars 58 av. J.-C. ; menaçant selon lui les alliĂ©s de Rome, tels les Éduens, un tel dĂ©placement de population associĂ© Ă  l’élection d’un roi chez les HelvĂštes apparaĂźt aux yeux du politicien comme une bonne raison de dĂ©clencher les hostilitĂ©s sous couvert de remise en ordre de la rĂ©gion. Cette expĂ©dition militaire est donc motivĂ©e par ses ambitions politiques, mais aussi par des intĂ©rĂȘts Ă©conomiques qui associent les Romains Ă  certaines nations gauloises clientes de Rome (Éduens, Arvernes, etc.).

Tout en menant ses campagnes, CĂ©sar maintient ses relations avec la classe politique romaine : Quintus Tullius Cicero, frĂšre de l’orateur Marcus Tullius Cicero, dit CicĂ©ron, commande ainsi une lĂ©gion en BelgiqueA 39 ; Publius et Marcus, les fils de Crassus, interviennent en Belgique puis en AquitaineA 40 ; Lucius Munatius PlancusA 41 et Marc Antoine seront Ă  AlĂ©siaA 42.

Quintus Tullius Cicero est un homme politique, militaire et auteur romain, frĂšre cadet du cĂ©lĂšbre orateur CicĂ©ron. Il naĂźt en 102 av. J.-C. Ă  Arpinum, une ville proche de Rome. AprĂšs une carriĂšre politique classique, passant par le cursus honorum jusqu’à la charge de prĂ©teur, il est proprĂ©teur en Asie puis participe Ă  la Guerre des Gaules en tant que lĂ©gat de lĂ©gion servant sous Jules CĂ©sar.

.

This is a weird and pointless argument.

4 Likes

I think if I, an almost-college educated dude (I’ll graduate in May), brought up the fact that I had been to college and had a library card, you would probably tell me that those things alone do not guarantee that someone is actually intelligent or knows anything about anything.

But since I’m going to be a college educated guy (with a degree in history!) and I have a library card, will you please tell me I’m smart? It’d mean a lot.

1 Like

It’s what happens when someone can’t let go of a grudge. Ancient Roman military commanders did not have the title of general as that term was not in use at the time. Also, the path to becoming a “general” was different and the duties and powers were also different. I was only pointing out how silly Tate is because he thinks he would have been on the level of Caesar or Marius. It was just some trivia but twojar just can’t help being gay and getting triggered by it.

An eloquent, wise response from such an educated individual.

No, in fact I’ll say the opposite as you lack reading comprehension. I was speaking from twojar’s point of view; how he sees me. I wouldn’t call myself a dude and I have more than one library card. People come out of college as smart, or as stupid, as they were when they went in.

It’s not a choice you know.

2 Likes