[quote]ZEB wrote:
Ross:
Yes, we all need an “adequate calorie intake.” However, that adequate level can be far easier to maintain if we are not doing endless (and needless)running just about each and every day. Sometimes to the point of nausea.
They also add Gymnastic balancing movements. Granted Gymnastics is a fine sport and I have quite a lot of respect for Gymnasts. However, what is the point of a Police Officer wasting his valuble training time on some nonsensical (for him at least) Gymnastic movement when he can be using that time for Squatting for example, with the appropriate set/rep system.
Here is my biggest problem with crossfit: There method trys to be all things to all people. Which by definition makes it a poorly constructed program. How can you craft a program specifically for a Police Officer and have that same program also be perfect for a Track & Field athlete and a Football player as well? You can’t! Crossfit would do well to get the advice of many top flight Coaches from all walks of life, such as what T-Nation does.
They brag about puking on that site! How many times do we have to read, on this very site (T-Nation), that this is not the sort of fitness regime that we need in order to build muscle? And in fact, not the best program to build cardio endurance. It, might however be the best program to promote burnout! Don’t get me wrong I have had many a Squat workout where I was ready to toss up some cookies, however that is the exception not the rule.
I am not stating that a crossfit workout will not get you into decent cardio condition. It may very well do that if you can continue the torrid pace over an extended period of time without burnout. And if you are one of those rare types who is blessed with a mesomorphic body type, it might not tear down to much muscle. But to recommend this type of training for a Police Officer is ridiculous!
Better you taylor a program specifically for the task at hand. As JD430 states quite succinctly regarding Police work: “The name of the game is short burst output.”
If a Police Officer is to train specifically for his job, he would not pursue any sort of program that tears down muscle the way crossfit in fact does!
Better we have a well muscled Police Officer who is capable of tapping into that power as need be during a typical Police action (yes there is a typical Police action). Also, better he look the part in order to deter someone from violence.
I don’t think the bad guys care how many times that you threw up during the past month. For that matter I’m sure they don’t care how well you can do a standing back tuck.
If you want a good program for Police work you need look no further than the T-Nation search engine.[/quote]
ZEB,
Again, your arguments regarding LEO training in particular sound somewhat persuasive and I am familiar with neither the rigors of the profession nor how to train for it, so I repeat: I'm not making any claims whatsoever about LEO training.
However, with regards to CrossFit in general, I disagree with you on at least one point: CrossFit's WorkOut of the Day (WOD) is not especially conducive to wasting muscle away or straining the CNS. CrossFit involves a lot of activities that strain the cardiovascular system, but steady-state aerobic work shows up no more often than once, maybe twice a month. Max lift days show up more frequently, but the exercises are constantly and very intelligently rotated to avoid overstimulus. Compared to a Westside PL training template, CrossFit's CNS load is very light. Compared to a distance runner's schedule, they do almost no running.
I don't endorse CrossFit without any reservations; right now, I am training the OLs, not doing the WOD, and I do find it a lot easier to gain weight squatting three times a week and periodizing my lifting normally. Ultimately, though, when I have built up my strength and speed to a better level through OL and I'm going for the total package - high scores across the board for every aspect of fitness - I'll do something like the WOD, even if I don't do the WOD as prescribed. It's just hard to practice weightlifting, gymnastics, and aerobic/anaerobic conditioning simultaneously without moving towards a CrossFit-style training template.