Nobody (from weightlifting) tells Simmons how to coach powerlifting, why does he think he can coach weightlifting? In my humble opinion, when you get to the highest levels of sport, the SAID principle applies to coaching as well.
In a college maybe. If your business is a strength sport, that sounds like a different story.
My (uninformed) opinion is that the major sport in America (football), is one where being a big, strong motherfucker is incredibly important. In most other countries in the world thatās not true. In Britain for example, our national sport is real football (soccer), in which being a big strong motherfucker is in no way an advantage.
If everyone in the world started playing American football, the US would become a lot more competitive in the weight room.
And always remember, low-bar back squats and heavy sets of fahves on the Conventional Deadlift will get an Olympic athlete better at the snatch and clean and jerk than whatever silly exercises their incompetent coaches are making them do. Technique doesnāt need to be emphasized for Olympic athletes because a clean is simply a shrug and jump, and a snatch is simply an expression of the mobility that we donāt believe in working on. Olympic athletes need to be tight in order to lift the most amount of weight possible.
Chad Wesley Smith has said in podcasts that he was (much) stronger and had better #s in explosive metrics than guys who were superior to him in the shot put. Not to put words in his mouth but I think he said that being too strong too early actually hindered his development of technique.
Closer to āhomeā, Brian Alsruhe is much stronger than Alan Thrall in the deadlift and squat, but Iāve seen a video where Thrall easily outperformed Alsruhe in flipping a very heavy tire for time.
So low bar is not the panacea to all deficiencies in sport, even strength sports; and neither is the conjugate method plus bands.
Well said. I can squat double my body weight, pull in the low 400s, and canāt throw a 12 pound shot more than 30 feet. Some things are just genetic, contrary to what the peanut gallery will shout at you (the personal trainers who claim that they can make kids āfasterā and āmore explosiveā with the use of bands and chains at the tender age of 9 comes to mind).
I remembered something today and as much as I hate to defend him⦠Rips whole Olympic statement was less to do with back squats. It had to do with the notion that allot of American lifters were too focused on form and technique while putting static strength on the back burner.
Ripās ābigā thing is you can use more weight with low bar than high bar, so American lifters need to do low bar, use more weight, get stronger -easy. Thatās whatās stupid.
Wrt deadlift, Iām not sure if he realizes that the technique used to ādeadliftā for weightlifting is different than that used for powerlifting. Because the analogy is the same for high bar vs. low bar.
Also, letās say the best OLers can clean 80% of what they squat (thatās on the low side I think); at some point getting stronger in the squat is irrelevant.
@T3hPwnisher didnāt the peanut gallery on the Starting Strength forums also attack you, the 650 lb. deadlifter, regarding your training methodologies way back in 2014 (after they invoked one of your blog posts and completely twisted its meaning)? I believe Rip eventually chimed in and said you were of āabove average intelligenceā.
@shrednation I have nothing against Starting Strength, but unfortunately his followers are a bit dogmatic ā to the point that they attacked somebody who got much, much stronger than them without doing the program.
In fairness, Rip was employing a lot of sarcasm when he said that to me, haha. But yeah, it was pretty silly. I admit, I took a little joy when he gave me a barb of āWell I wonder what 600lb deadlifters do when they want to pull 700lbsā and I gave him an answer, referencing my pull that was higher than his, haha.