Hey guys thanks for replying.
As some have pointed out, Strength shouldn’t rule over technique, which I am sure everybody already agrees on so no need to get all captain obvious, but I do often find myself trying to finish a choke that for one reason or another just isn’t connecting properly.
I might get a really nice deep collar grip but if I’m sparring against a good opponent or just a very strong one, I oftentimes loose some inches of the grip before applying the choke. I’m sure you have been in the same situation many times yourself but rather than letting go of that grip which you have been fighting to get and starting all over again I see no problem in filling in the gap with strength. What ever makes the guy tap!
In addition, if your fighting against a really good opponent, you might not get a second chance to get that grip.
[quote]slimjim wrote:
[quote]cycobushmaster wrote:
[quote]zecarlo wrote:
[quote]cycobushmaster wrote:
when i was at a Jeff Curran seminar a while back he talked about gassing in a fight when he put a triangle on. he said because the the guy held out so long, his legs gassed on him. he said that he started training isometric-type submission holds after that.
just my .02[/quote]
The problem wasn’t his strength or endurance but that the hold was not applied well. If you are actually choking someone it is impossible to hold out for more than a few seconds. In fact, the better applied the choke is, the less strength it takes to finish the person. Improving strength and endurance to make up for a weakness in technique is the wrong way to address the issue. [/quote]
i’m pretty sure Curran, being a 2nd degree blackbelt, understands that…
i think the point that he was making was that sometimes you need to hold a technique for longer with different people, circumtances, etc, and therefore need to prepare your endurance for that.
[/quote]
lol, it is so common in bjj for people to say ‘worry about technique, not strength’ (or conditioning) etc etc…while true, let’s not discount the benefits of strength and conditioning…andre galvao had an interview a few months ago and when presented the question, ‘who will win, the guy with better technique or the guy with better conditioning’ with some qualifications regarding teh guy with conditionings skill (obviously we’re talking guys with grappling ability, not triathletes) galvao said he thought the guy with better conditioning would be better suited to win the match due to his ability to use proper technique later in the round…because he wasnt tired and still able to perform the moves correctly[/quote]
I couldn’t agree more on this but it goes beyond the bjj scene I think.
Prior to bjj I had been doing mma, wing tsun and alot of other MA’s and I still have a vivid memory of people giving me that “your using to much strength” which I’m sure I was being somewhat big and strong at the time, but it just seemed like it would only come up when they couldn’t get whatever they were trying to do to work.
Offcause if you have really poor technique you should be working hard not to use your strength but if your techniques are solid, I see no problem using strength as I said before.
Ultimately I don’t think there are many athletes left in the world of combat sports that don’t strength train.
[quote]kmcnyc wrote:
As usual there is a variety of opinions here.
without attacking anyone- >.< I think grip strength is the only place in grappling
where strength trumps technique
as for conditioning - and grip they are tied together, if your conditioning fails your or you gass,
so will your grip.
try signing your name after a wrestling/grappling/judo match.
if your hands shake after grappling you can do the math-
If you have never felt that feeling - you are either in great shape or your not working hard enough
As for ‘death grip’ it is part of the technique, but don’t let it get in the way of finishing or transitioning.
for people saying your applying it wrong if you use strength- your not always going to have
a perfect textbook situation so you are going to have to squeeze.
Or if you have that goon who is made of rubber or just wont tap - they are out there.
get your conditioning down- and your grip wont fail.
Personally - COC never did anything for me- while I wont say they are easy- they did not help.
Kroc rows high rep heavy DB rows
Gi or Rope pullups or any kind of rope work-
pullups while squashing tennis balls ( on top of the bar) are awesome.
those three have helped me the most- but really after wrestling playing Judo for a long time-
my grip is prob the only decent strength I have. [/quote]
I’m having a hard time visualizing the tennis ball pull ups… How do you hold on to the bar while squeezing the balls?
I don’t agree on the whole pensil “if your not shivering, your not working hard enough” test and I really can’t see the correlation between shivering and not working hard enough.