[quote]Battle Pope wrote:
[quote]grandin11 wrote:
How can he say someone who does bodyweight exercises is stronger than someone who lifts weights considering the load of bodyweight exercises basically never changes? Just show him videos of Ronnie, Jay, etc. lifting weights and if he has 2 brain cells to rub together he should shut up. If not, listen to his argument, laugh, and ignore him.[/quote]
well, you can increase the load by either eating a ton and putting on weight, or by changing the leverages. Dominic Lacasse is a pretty elite gymnast, he’s 5’7" and about 160lbs. Every training video i’ve seen doesn’t show him lifting weights, he’s all bodyweight. But, sure, eugene sandow was 5’9 1/4", and weighed 202 lbs. These stats are from roughly the same age of each person.
And sandow wouldn’t be considered a “big guy” by today’s standards either. Obviously he didn’t use steroids, since they didn’t exist. Clearly, this guy who trained 100 years ago, is bigger than the guy who trains today with just bodyweight.
http://www.dominiclacasse.com/domlacasse.php
[/quote]
I agree Sandow was not a “big” guy but most of his training consisted of bodyweight training as with most strongman. Bert Assirati, a wrestler and strongman, in the 1930’s also used bodyweight training, he performed one-armed handstands as part of his training, at 230 llbs. This doesn’t mean they hated weights just no access to them 24 hours a day. Moreover, today’s bodyweight training the dirty dog and every asinine variation won’t increase power or mass, the authentic oldschool system involved training like gymnast; one armed variants of pullups, headstand, squats pushups, and iron crosses on gymnast rings.
One thing I would like to ask is has anyone ever met a powerlifter or bodybuilder not incorporate some sort of bodyweight training? Dips, pull ups, and push ups are staples just as squats, deadlift, and bench press but an individual who incorporates all of this far more likely to succeed in strength and size than the individual who snubs one for the other. In short there is some truth to what he says but why bother worrying about what some tool at work says let him have his dirty dog and incorrectly performed dive bomber push ups. Keep doing what you love and the results will shut him up.