I want to say something that may sound unintentionally harsh or like I am bashing Carter, because I’m not. He is a professional in this game and I’m just a 30 something insurance broker who lifts weights in his garage. That being said I like interacting with you and I’m only bringing this up because of the last post I responded to here and it is solely my opinion so it can be taken or left.
You were not too fat to bulk. You do not have to “bulk”. If you want to gain muscle that will not make you feel ‘underwhelmed’ by your own words, it’s not going to happen in 6-8 weeks. It doesn’t matter what workout plan you pick, unless you take the needle or orals, 6-8 weeks at BEST will be what, 2-3 pounds of muscle? You also don’t have to get fat to gain muscle. If you look at the next 12 months, the amount of total muscle mass you gain will be due to how long you are in a surplus. Every time you diet down you are taken away that time, and I’ve said it alot but it is so much easier and faster to lose fat than to gain muscle.
If you took a solid 6 months, and ate a modest surplus, 300-400 cals, that’s going to add about 15 lbs to you. Done right, maybe 5-6 of that will be fat, the rest muscle and water. Now if you eat like crap, back off cardio etc because you are in the ‘bulking’ mindset(what most of us fall victim to) that number will be higher. If you treated gaining with the same fervor as you do cutting, you’ll be fine. Then what, spend 5-6 weeks dieting and you are back but with 6 months, not 6 weeks worth of muscle gain.
I know this was unsolicited advice but I hope it made some sense. I think it just needed to be said before you embark on a long 5/3/1 journey. Dont sacrifice next year’s physique for a temporary and inconsequential body fat % goal which nobody every notices unless you walk around naked or shirtless all the time. You don’t have to get fat to get big.
And yes, I know I just invited people to debate, but I dont want to take over his log, this is just directed at Samul from someone who has been in his shoes and done the same thing years back.
Edit - Also wanted to add this, Abs, like full on abs, are a temporary status unless you have the genetics or drugs to take keeping you that lean year round. Trying to stay at that level of lean will just delay your end result. Once you get to the size close enough to where you feel happy or glad to be, then you can focus on staying lean and adding 1-2 pounds a year.






