[quote]Professor X wrote:
Anonymas wrote:
ok, i wasnt questioning the reliability I was just genuinely intrigued as to how u knew, the only places I have learnt about how people trained were from the books they wrote, but I dont have a large collection
Have you read this thread? I spoke to anyone and everyone that was bigger than me from the time I started training. I know how these guys train because the one thing I did not do is simply rely on what I read somewhere.
That doesn’t mean I didn’t read books either. However, knowledge without experience has very little real world application. Would you want your heart surgery done by someone who had read a lot about heart surgeries or someone who had actually done quite a few with success?[/quote]
One obviously needs practical experience (at some point) to be able to really make sense of what one is reading as well.
In most bodybuilding books (except Ronnie’s, for example), ramping is never mentioned.
Arnold didn’t follow the same style of ramping we use today (he did more than just the last set all-out and kept reducing reps as he went up in weight, for example… There’s one big reason why competitors today are larger. They actually did improve upon the old methods and made their routines more progression friendly and usually less tendon-shredding, combine that with proper off-season eating and generally better diets… Of course it’s not the only reason, but it plays a much bigger role than many people want to believe), but people reading his encyclopedia will likely assume that he just used the same weight for all sets done because that’s what they hear from authors and read in the muscle-mags: “4*8-12” or some such, which may not even be wrong…
Except that if it concerns a real bodybuilding routine/pro-routine, it usually means “started at 135lbs on the bench for 8 or so, went up to 405 for 8-10 over the course of 4 sets” or some such. That makes a huge difference when it comes to overall-stress on the joints/tendons, how much you can lift on your work set (usually more, as your nervous system and muscles are warmed up way better) and how easily you can progress.
So yeah… Unless you’ve actually seen those guys train, you won’t likely be able to interpret the information you get from their books correctly and so we get all these “pro routines = massive overtraining” nonsense and lots of people making no strength gains when following similar routines because they simply misinterpreted the information (of course the information could also be flat-out wrong… Especially in the magazines).