[quote]Basso wrote:
assbuster wrote:
Basso wrote:
assbuster wrote:
Injuries can come with any lift, box squats done properly are an incredible asset, if they scare you, that’s your business, I have no problem with that but saying they are only for beginners becuase some idiot you know did them wrong and got hurt is a bit ignorant. I don’t do a westside workout but I take what works for me from everything I learn, Westside provides a lot of good info that can be used.
BTW you can keep your personnal hangups about the military to yourself, I choose my profession and regardless of your opinions will continue to protect your freedoms.
First off Box Squats are great for people needing to hone their squatting technique or that are just learning to squat, but box squats are not optimal for quad development such as full range back, front or overhead squats. Why do you really need to bounce your ass off a box for if you know how to squat?
The problems I have with box squats are they are too restrictive in ROM and as I said before if for some reason you lose your balance on the way down be ready for a serious injury. Lose it on any of the above mentioned squats and you can shed the bar very easily without injury. It’s the stupid box I have a problem with from a safety standpoint. That’s why you shouldn’t go very heavy with them, that’s not their purpose.
Now regarding the military comment… I feel I’m entitled since I am ex-military and I was out there protecting your freedoms and right to be the smart ass you are when you were probably still eating baby food and crapping your diapers. So don’t preach that God and country bullshit to me I know it only too well. The difference is when I was in we were called “war mongers” and “baby killers”. Now you’re all “heroes”. My point is having a mind of your own. Don’t be such a blockheaded soldier on everything in life. Think for yourself. Don’t let Dave Tate, the Westside Guys, the president, your C.O. or anyone else tell you how to think. That’s what I hated about the military; no place for free thinkers.
A.B.
You were in the military awhile ago I can tell, anyway I’ve been in over 20yrs and I still have my free will. Yes I have to obey orders, but I’ve earned the right to ask why now. Anyway like I said before I’m not a Westside worshipper, in fact I disagree with a lot of their teaching, I used them as an example for box squats because they are well known for their box squatting! I box squat because they work!
Bouncing is not allowed, the box should be low enough to not restrict ROM, in fact I use it alot to get trainees to go low enough! Done properly you sit back onto the box, come to a complete stop. Box squats are not the ol’ stick a bench and bounce off the bottom. When I first learned to box squat properly I could barely get 400 off the box, and I can squat over 600 to the floor. I will agree to disagree on this but from your comments I really believe you do not know how to box squat properly or you would change your mind.
Anyway I’m not trying to get into some arguement here, this is my last post on this thread.
[/quote]
I agree with the bouncing statement. You come to a complete stop with box squats. You don’t use it to rebound off of. That’s high school stuff. For those with very long femurs, this exercise is a great tool for insuring adequate ROM (if that is desired by the lifter). Box squats are actually harder to perform because you can’t take advantage of the stretch reflex like you can with a traditional squat. How many people do you see pause at the bottom of a traditional squat? Not many. Box squats develop starting strength, as well.