[quote]Christian Thibaudeau wrote:
[quote]Mutsanah wrote:
Thib:
My 1RM on semi-sumo DL is approx. 500 but my Oly Squat is only 365, squat has always pretty much stunk even though I really do work at it - Front Sq max 315, I work both every week at 2 seperate sessions, DL is ‘easy’ for me and very enjoyable. I can close grip bench more than I front sq! Sheesh…
Stuck with a stinky squat or what?[/quote]
In most people there is little correlation between the deadlift and squat, especially if your deadlift stance is different than your squatting stance. Don’t get me wrong, there IS some correlation between both lifts, but not as much as you would think.
The thing is that both lifts are suited for different body types. For example, my deadlift always sucked compared to my back and front squat. With practice and proper training I was able to bring up my deadlift, but it will always be a ‘‘weaker lift’’ compared to the squat for me.
The reason is that I have short limbs (arms and legs) and a long torso. An ideal built for the squat (and bench), a lousy one for the deadlift and no amount of training can correct that.
And to be honest, your deadlift and squat strength are not THAT out of balance. Many strength coaches believe that your deadlift strength should be around 1.25 times your full squatting strength. Which would be around 400lbs for you with a 320-325lbs front squat (so your front squat is not out of balance).
A lot of people will be quick to point out that most competitive powerlifters squat a lot more than they can deadlift. True, but keep in mind that:
- The squat suit and knee wraps help the squat A LOT more than they can help the deadlift. In fact, some powerlifters have reported that a power suit and knee wraps hurt their deadlift. If you look at the results of powerlifters from the 70s and 80s, their deadlift was almost always higher than their squat.
That’s because they had limited supporting gear which did not artificially pump up their squat numbers. It is also the reason why squat records have increased by 200-300lbs over the past 15 years whereas the deadlift record is VERY slowly moving up.
- Powerlifters with short limbs are advantaged in the bench and squat (2 lifts) and long limbed powerlifters are advantaged in the deadlift (1 lift). Since the best powerlifter is determined either via his 3 lifts total OR by his bench press (there are no squat or deadlift only meets, but there are bench press contests) then the short limbed lifter will often come up at the top (since he is advantaged in 2 lifts versus 1).
So when you look at the results from the top powerlifters for comparison, it is normal to find stronger squats than deadlifts since these guys are built for squat.
-
A lot of powerlifting systems focus more on the squat and bench press (Westside for example) only deadlifting occasionally. Even though both the squat and deadlift use many of the same muscles, you do become better at what you practice. This is yet one more reason why you see powerlifters with higher squat than deadlift numbers.
-
Squat depth in many powerlifting federations has been cut short a lot. While the IPF is still severe and strict on squatting depth, many other federations give the lifter a bit more leeway for the sake of seeing the records go up. Since you can’t ‘‘cheat’’ a deadlift by cutting down the range of motion, the comparison between the squat and deadlift is harder to make since we no longer are comparing the FULL squat to the deadlift.
The bottom line is that you can’t compare your own strength ratios to what powerlifters are putting up. You are actually not that out of balance.[/quote]
Thib:
Thanks for your in-depth answer; considering where I started I suppose I should be pretty happy. I’m just the opposite of your body type - long legs, longer arms.
6’1" height but my arm span is 6’5" - Just measured to see how I was proportioned - holy moley! I’m an orangutan. That’s why DL is so much easier than squat. Probably also why semi-sumo DL suits me even more since I can let upper back and shoulders slightly round towards bar a la Bob Peoples while still keeping a tight arch in lower back.
I’ll still keep working on squat - seeing myself with a 405 front squat one of these days…hopefully at the same time that I hit a 405 close grip bench…