[quote]WhiteFlash wrote:
[quote]scj119 wrote:
[quote]MattyXL wrote:
No reason to calm down…Other than Irving, why shouldnt he get some votes as ROY? I didnt say win it, I said get some notice. Knight, Walker, Thomas and Brooks all play for horrendous teams, Shump has been one of the main reasons the Knicks are looking good for the playoffs…if shumpert got the same PT on those poor teams he would put up similar stats.
[/quote]
I hate that line of thinking. Why should someone get votes for an award if we know they don’t deserve to win it? The whole “he should be mentioned in the discussion even though he shouldn’t win it” argument really annoys me (you see it a lot with MVP discussions in every sport). It’s basically just fans of a certain team wanting people to talk more about their guys.
That being said, you can’t rule out people who you haven’t seen play. Shumpert has nowhere NEAR the offensive game of Kyrie Irving, on any team, sorry bro. No matter which team you play on, bad or good, you have to put up those stats against NBA defenders. Irving runs the pick and roll like a 5-year vet, from the couple of games I’ve seen of him. It’s downright scary. Shumpert would NOT put up a 19/4/6 with 47% / 41% / 87% shooting splits on any team, period.
Saying Shump isn’t in the running for ROY doesn’t mean he’s not a good player, but there’s actually a much better crop of rookies this year than people thought of. Isaiah Thomas on the Kings has been awesome since starting, Kenneth Faried is doing things for Denver that they badly need, Kawhi Leonard getting serious run for the #1 or 2 seed in the West.
Also if you want to talk young guards defense, have you seen Avery Bradley? Holy crap (he’s a 2nd year player but still).[/quote]
When Bradley was in highschool I thought he had the potential to be Westbrook 2.0. He’s not quite as athletic or offensive minded but he’s a MUCH better man defender, and has some pretty serious upside. Kind of seems like they’re grooming him to take over for Rondo when he leaves, however that happens.[/quote]
I think they’re grooming him to take over for Allen. The Rondo-Bradley backcourt has somehow been monstrously effective so far despite the lack of shooting. And it’s incredibly disruptive defensively to have them both out there.
You’re right on with Westbrook… his size/athleticism has made him overrated as a man defender. Gambles too often and isn’t that good at it.