BPC,
I think you are right on with your assertions; get strong/powerful in the weight room, work on sport specific stuff when you practice! The sport-specific stuff has gone far enough, people…let it go.
Now, as far as building “general” athleticism, sure you can do it…when kids are kids! You’re not going to develop a 40 year old couch potato into an athlete. “General” athleticism is built by making your kids play sports, getting out and running, and just being kids in general. Kids who spend all day playing Sega and sitting on their ass will never be good athletes.
Stay strong
MR
[quote]BPC wrote:
Mike,
Basically I love to “hoop” 2 times per week just playground style for fun. I also want to get really strong and fast.
What are your opinions of this comment by Scott Sonnon: "You aren’t going to become graceful by benching more, deadlifting heavier, or squatting more explosively. The inter-muscular coordination gained through these lifts only increase your ability to do those gross, isolated movements. It may or may not have a positive effect on your other activities. The honest trainers will admit that the academic jury still sits behind closed doors deciding the fate of whether that type of training transfers into other activities even at all.
The reason that many lack grace and lack the ability to produce consistent and comprehensive graceful clients is simple. It is because they only think in terms of inter-muscular coordination. They only know this because it is quantifiable. However, QUALITY of movement, ?Biomechanical Efficiency? and ?Neuomuscular Efficiency? (discussed in Body-Flow) remains the elusive element which shackles them to robotic, low-quality movement.
Besides inter-muscular coordination, there is also Neural Drive (in old strongman speak known as ?nerve force?), Intra-Muscular Coordination (known as ?muscle control? in the Golden Age of true strongmen), and Disinhibition (basically getting out of the way of your unlimited capabilities."
Scott often states that lifting heavy and pursuing maximal strength is not the panacea of training. Obviously, he’s training for martial arts and you are a powerlifter so that’s different. However, my experience in martial arts and sports in general is that strength helps tremendously in addition to speed, range of motion ,etc.
Do you think it basically comes down to: get as strong/explosive in the weightroom as you can and perfect your skill of choice (in my case hoops) on the court? Is sport specific stuff overrated? Is there even such a thing as developing “general” athleticism as Scott says? Perfect example of what I mean is that last week I rollerskated for the first time in like 15 years and had a hard time (plus the fact that I’m 6’2 tall) but I can play basketball fine.
[/quote]