While I’m not Stu, I am one of his clients!
We don’t do macro borrowing or cheating. We do carb cycling, and also added a re-feed day once per week when we got 4 weeks out. My metabolism was trashed, and after process of elimination and trying a few things, we thought adding carbs and cals would be best, and boy did it work out well. Again there are significant differences between a well structured re-feed and a cheat.
REFEED
-Carb intake increases for the day, up to 1.5x-2x normal depending on the individual and how they want to structure it.
-Fat intake is very minimal for the day as your body is hyper sensitive, and having high carbs AND high fat in your blood can increase chances of storing body fat
-Protein intake for the day drops to 1g per pound to leave room for the carbs. Carbs are muscle sparing in nature, so dropping protein for one day will have no negative effects at all.
CHEAT
-Eat whatever, typically high carb and high fat foods like pizza or cheeseburgers. Opening the door to store excess body fat, hold a lot of water which will throw off the scale and mirror for a couple of days depending on the individual.
Cheating or macro borrowing just opens the doors for inconsistencies, mind games and a host of other problems. As @BrickHead mentioned in his thread, if you want to lose weight a predictable rate, there’s no wiggle room. The closer you get to the show and the leaner you are, the more important it is to be rigidly consistent.
In terms of RPE that has to be up to the individual to gauge their own effort and know how to auto regulate and listen to your body. The goal is ALWAYS to train with as much intensity as possible, every time, but some days you’re just gassed and can barely keep yourself on your feet, you’ve got to be able to know how hard you can go without digging yourself too deep. This just takes time and getting used to training in that state.
Every coach is different. For me, Stu looked at my training logs, adjusted the order of some exercises and a couple of rep ranges. Some coaches will give a training program to their client and say “do this,” but I think ultimately what matters more is the intensity of the training and the diet, it’s very easy to over complicate a training program. Stu and I would often talk about how training programs can really get over complicated. The order of exercises can make a big difference over time though, he made some adjustments to the structure of my back workout and we made some serious progress relatively quickly there.
Personally I rarely did ramping except for on some compound movements, like DB presses or squats, otherwise I would base my working set weight on what I previously did last session, also gauging my energy level and strength that day, and stick with that for all sets of the exercise. As the prep continues there is typically a slow and steady decline in strength, so it’s extremely important to auto regulate and be aware of your body.