[quote]DixiesFinest wrote:
[quote]angry chicken wrote:
You guys seem to know your stuff so, can someone please explain something to me that has been buggin me for a while?
Why on earth would ANYONE in their right mind believe that Mary was virgin? Seriously, is it because she SAID she was? Was there an ancient gynecologist back then that VERIFIED it? And wasn’t she like… MARRIED when Jesus was born? (did she have sex AFTER he was born? if so, did this not “compromise” her purity in the eyes of some?)
I mean if someone made that claim today, would you believe them? Why should we believe it back then? It seems to me that a SHIT TON of that religion is pinned to (in MY mind) a rather dubious “fact”…
By the way, I think Jesus was a cool guy and don’t take anything away from him - he showed GREAT courage. I would follow his example even if his mom and dad had sex…
I mean, all this stuff is based on shit that NO ONE CAN PROVE, yet many of you argue about it like it happened right in front of you and you witnessed it personally…
Please, ENLIGHTEN me…[/quote]
http://www.catholic.com/library/Mary_Ever_Virgin.asp[/quote]
OK, so I read the fisheaters.com and it proved absolutely nothing. The catholic.com link states that according to the Protoevangelium (could someone elaborate on how we are SURE the Catholic Church didn’t alter those records in the same spirit with which they transfer pedophile priests around?) Mary’s birth was “prophesied” (imagine that) and her mother, St. Anne (who apparently DID have sex) “vowed she would devote the child to the service of the Lord”. So in order to “guard her ceremonial cleanliness”, she was to have a “guardian” and Joseph (a widower who had children already) was chosen to be her spouse.
And when it was discovered that Mary was pregnant, Joseph had to answer to the temple authorities for “violating a virgin” and Mary had to answer to them for “breaking her vow”.
So let’s come back to planet earth for a moment. What is a FAR more probably scenario:
A, Joseph’s wife died so he hadn’t had sex in a LONG time, so when he had “access” to a young, nubile girl, through MARRIAGE, he did what MOST red blooded men would do and took full advantage of the situation. Fearing the consequences when her resulting pregnancy was sure to reveal his indiscretion to the temple authorities (who for all we know may have cut off his wiener for "violating the Lord’s property or other such nonsense), he LIED and convinced Mary, a young and impressionable girl, to LIE and say it was the Holy Spirit so that they would both not get into trouble. They had OPPORTUNITY and MOTIVE to conceal the truth about their sexual relationship.
OR is it MORE LIKELY that:
B, Joseph, Mary’s HUSBAND, didn’t have sex with her and the “Holy Spirit” did (which, by definition, defiled her and knocked her up in the process, but I digress).
What does COMMON FUCKING SENSE tell you?
If I am missing any facts, please point them out.