[quote]Scott M wrote:
undeadlift wrote:
Well, you can’t be best at both worlds. You can’t lose fat and not lose muscle EFFECTIVELY at the same time. It’s like scratching your ass while you’re in a 100m dash.
You see, weight loss is not selective. You will lose muscle and fat once you reduce your caloric intake. However, you can MINIMIZE muscle loss by doing a strength routine while you diet. It also helps if you eat less fat and more protein.
I’d also check out the physique clinics of those endo guys if I were you.
I’m sorry but I couldn’t disagree more with this. I don’t see guys that know what they are doing lose tons of muscle getting in shape. Not bodybuilding contest lean which is a whole different story. I DO SEE people who panic diet and do crazy things with their diet and training to try to get lean who come out looking like skeletons. [/quote]
True, but I think people get lost in the process without a full understanding of how their own body works. When dieting, your main goal is to lose fat and hold onto the muscle mass you have. At least, it is your goal if you have half a clue what you are doing.
Some MAY experience a gain in muscle mass, however, if they had approached this as if that was the intent, they would have simply slowed down their own progress. That “gain” may be based on hormonal factors, or other variables that are basically beyond their control.
Many more when dieting WILL experience a loss in muscle mass because it takes a deep knowledge of what makes your own body adapt to prevent this. Most people jumping on treadmills for an hour before they lift some light weights really quick don’t have any sort of perspective on how to build or maintain their muscle mass. Their diets are usually much less than optimal and they don’t know how to push themselves in the weight room.
Obviously, experience is the greatest teacher. Very few people, however, are willing to put that time in and learn what works best for them. They are more likely to simply follow some guru while eternally remaining lost.
If someone’s goal was to avoid muscle loss during dieting, they would first need an understanding of what it takes for their body to gain muscle mass and maintain it optimally. Most of these guys are attempting to bypass that completely.
I haven’t seen that work for very many people yet.