Lifting Program Confusion

[quote]austin_bicep wrote:
don’t ask for advice if you can’t handle constructive criticism, take it as a grain of salt. your obvioulsy doing alot wrong because not only is your bench weak, you couldn’t increase your max in a whole year. from what you’re saying, you do sets of 3-5 and thats wht i do and it works awesome for me so i guess i cant give you any advice besides eat more and lift heavy, the plataeu will eventually break it depends on how dedicated you are to breaking it. and let me define detication so i dont here a smart ass remark from you. Dedication in lifting is striving to increase your physical capacity in a smart and planned regimen. not doing a bullshit routine day in and day out like you’ve been doing[/quote]

i can very much so handle the criticism. i’m more or less mad at myself for having no clue wtf has been going on. when i got mad about the mental thing, i was thinking back to when that merlin character came on here and started saying how the only thing holding me back from increasing my bench by like 200 pounds tomorrow is my mind, in which i called total bullshit on and it pissed me off that he was so set in his ways yet would never back it up by going and automatically benching 200 lbs more tomorrow than his current pr.

so you’re suggesting that ws4sb is a bullshit routine day in and day out like i’ve been doing?

take what i’ve said as getting mad but i’m just trying to get answers.

[quote]Sentoguy wrote:
lifter85 wrote:

Well I’ve heard if you want to get big you need to focus on strength first so you can get more hypertrophy (ex someone benching 135 10 times is gona have less hypertrophy than someone benching 225 10 times), so essentially they need to be working on strength first before hypertrophy.

To answer though, I’d like to get big of course, but also have strength.

Also, all my other lifts have gone up, except bench.

Yes, increasing strength is an integral part of building muscle, I’m not arguing against that. I was asking just to make certain that your primary goal was muscle (as you didn’t specifically say that it was).

You are also correct that in order to put on large amounts of muscle, you must expose them to significantly higher levels of overload/weight. But, this does not have to be done in a powerlifting context (i.e. low reps, ME days, etc…). If you say started at 135 for 10 reps and just focused on increasing the load or doing more reps with the same load every time you hit the gym, then you would eventually get to 225 for 10 reps. You don’t need to lift powerlifting style in order to get stronger.

I realize that you were probably following the advice of someone with good intentions who pointed you in the direction of WS4SB, as once again it’s a successful program and has produced results in quite a few trainees. So, I’m not faulting you for following the program, nor am I contradicting the advice that you need to get stronger.

I’m simply saying that if you have indeed given the program an honest chance to work (which I would consider a year to be long enough of a chance) and it has not produced significant results, then perhaps you might want to try something else.

On the other hand, if all your other lifts have gone up, your weight has gone up and you are happy with the program (other than the bench), then perhaps another course of action is called for.

First, I’d agree with the poster who suggested to take a deloading period (I’d honestly suggest you might even want to take a complete break from lifting). Your CNS may need a break, and you may find that a couple weeks after coming back (or possibly even the first workout after) that you break through your plateau.

Second, while BB bench has a big ego component to it, and is one of the power lifts (hence the focus on it in a powerlifting inspired program like WS4SB), it’s not necessarily the best chest builder out there. Personally I feel that DB bench is a better chest builder and tends to be easier on my shoulder joints as well.

So, you might want to just give flat BB bench a break for a while (read months) and work on getting strong at a different bench variation (DB, inclines, machine). Keep progressing on that movement until you eventually hit a plateau with it (and you will, everyone does). At that point, you may decide that you either:

  1. want to try a different variation of bench (pick one)

  2. like DB’s for building chest more than BB (if you chose a DB variation)

  3. need to work on a specific part of your chest

Or, if you really want to you could go back to flat BB bench and once again work on improving it. Be warned that even at this point you probably won’t be lifting more than you are right now (though it’s possible that you might). But, you should have built some muscle in that time and should be able to top your current numbers in the bench in a fairly short period of time.

Once again, I’m not trying to confuse you or contradict that advice that has been given to you. You do need to get stronger if you want bigger muscles. Just realize that there is more than one way to go about doing that. And, if building muscle is your primary goal and the program you are currently on isn’t giving you the results you’re after, then perhaps it’s time to try something else.

Finally, before you do decide to change programs, make absolutely certain that your diet is in check (i.e. you are gaining weight consistently). If not, then fix that first. Honestly that should pretty much take care of the problem, but if it doesn’t then perhaps try switching routines.

Good training,

Sentoguy[/quote]

Thanks for the advice, much appreciated. Honestly I would choose db’s over bb but for some reason our gym only goes up to 75 lb db’s (college gym), and i already did 75’s for 12 reps last school year. kinda makes it pointless, imo.

well this kind of surprised me. today i went in for my repetition upper body day, and managed to get 135 25 times. However, I’ve read so much about this keeping the elbows tucked in, that I had been keeping my elbows almost inverted inside of my wrists. This got me discouraged as the weight just wasn’t going up like that.

After looking at some pics of powerlifters lifting with this method, I noticed they were more like 45 degree angles than way inside. So, instead of 90 degrees, and instead of inverted, I went for 45 degrees and was amazed at how easy the bar went up. Now if only I can control 225 for a significant amount of reps, I’ll be good. Hopefully this might be the only problem.

[quote]lifter85 wrote:
SkyzykS wrote:
Well, heres the thing. Everybody wants to do super mega-powerlifting garan-fuckin-teed to get the last bit of strength you have type of workouts, THAT AREN’T THE RIGHT CHOICE FOR THIER TRAINING AGE!

Why are you lifting in the 3-5 rep range?

So this man is suggesting that after 17 months of lifting I am not ready for ws4sb. I guess all the girls that do this program aren’t ready for it either? I’m doing it to gain strength.

i’ve heard so many different things that i don’t know what to think anymore. first i see n00bs don’t need as much training, but that 3x a week short full body is best, then i hear n00bs need more volume and shit. apparently no one knows what they’re talking about.[/quote]

Yes. This man is suggesting that. Look at Thibs most recent article and his volume recomendations for at least the first couple of years. Look at what your friends who are making progress reps/set and sets/movement volume amounts are, and look at your own.

You will see that you should be working in the high volume range, where you will make very good gains in size and strength.

I realy would like to see exactly where and in what context it was said that nobs don’t need as much training. There are a lot f people who know what they are talking about, and they ALL recomend the same thing for the first couple of years.

VOLUME. Fuck the latest and the greatest trend with cool initials.

SW4SB is a 1 week recovery cycle so it’s aimed at intermediates. Beginners would have faster gains on Starting strength, or basically any program where they go progressively heavier each workout.

WS4SB is a good program and you are probably ready for it but if it’s not working do something else. There are lots of other good intermediate program. Going with too advanced a program will get you results, just not very fast.

The fact that you have plateaued for a year doesn’t mean you should go to a beginner program, exactly the opposite. It means you should change your routine, perhaps with even a longer periodization, although I doubt it. It also indicates a stubbornness beyond what’s reasonable. The real problem may be that you are beyond what you can achieve with a canned intermediate program. You have to get in touch with your own unique recovery needs and learn what works for you.

Your friends may be genetically better endowed for lifting. Going from 140 to 280 in 9 months is not unusual for a gifted beginner. Your friend that doesn’t appear to plan his workouts but benches 405 may just have good instincts for what works for him. Soon he will need coach to take him to the next level. Both of those guys will likely stall soon as they will both get to a point where they have to change.