[quote]WhiteFlash wrote:
[quote]audiogarden1 wrote:
[quote]WhiteFlash wrote:
[quote]Robert A wrote:
[quote]humble wrote:
[quote]FightinIrish26 wrote:
Saying that Lesnar “has a couple years experience” is not necessarily true. The guy was a world class wrestler, which translates pretty well to MMA.
Just sayin’.[/quote]
Bro, you’re usually well versed but this is just american hype machine. He’s not that world class a wrestler… bull rushes dont make you a great wrestler. 265 pounts helps
[/quote]
He is a NATIONAL class wrestler. He was champ of a shallow division. His size and strength pretty much mean that he was very effective at using his wrestling, even if I think he was less technical than Coleman, Randleman, or Kerr in terms of wrestling skill.
He also displayed a very good gameplan from the top in shutting down Mir in their second fight.
My opinion of Brock was that he didn’t “deserve” the title shot, but he won the fight so I cannot say too much bad about him.
He clearly beat Mir in their rematch. He managed to make it through Carwin, which was pretty impressive considering what Carwin had done at the time.
I was surprised he did not try to shoot for more takedowns against Overeem, but it was a good match up. Overeem’s K-1 win puts him at world class for kickboxing, but his MMA record going into last night was of being a 25-11 205’er who went undefeated by moving up in weight and fighting lackluster competition. Prior to last night his best win at heavyweight was Werdum, and his stand up did not look unbeatable in that fight. I am not sure destroying Buentillo, James Thompson, Tod Duffee and the rest is proof that he is not the same fighter who was beaten by Shogun and Diet Nog twice each. If you are as down on Lesnar as you seem, than might you argue he still has to prove himself as a top five MMA heavyweight?
My feeling about Overeem is that last night’s showing and his K-1 wins prove that anyone at heavyweight who stands in front of him is going to be in massive trouble. His Werdum fight makes me wonder if he can handle the threat of takedowns mixed with striking, something Lesnar did not try in his brief time against Reem, or a fighter who uses jabs and straights well. Werdum caught him a few times in their fight.
I think Cain may be a threat, because of his hands and ability to mix strikes with takedowns. JDS may be able to do well with his jab, but I would want to know if he has a ground game to threaten with. I think Carwin would be in serious trouble against Overeem. Even though Carwin has great power, Lesnar actually tries to jabe MORE than Carwin and I think trying to match power shots with Reem would make for a short night.
Regards,
Robert A[/quote]
If Carwin traded power shots with Overeem Carwin would win. The guy throw’s one hit ko’s from either hand coming from literally any concievable angle. Overeem is a beast, but their power is on completely different levels. Carwin has the most 1 shot power in all of MMA. Not saying he’s the best striker [he isn’t] or best boxer [he isn’t], just that no one can sit there and trade with him. He connects flush, it’s over. [/quote]
Strongly disagree with this one. Both guys hit hard as fuck, i cant say definitively who hits harder, but if Carwin stands and bangs with Overeem, Carwin gets smashed, even worse than he did against JDS.
BTW, Carwin hit Lesnar with literally dozens upon dozens of power shots from top position with all his weight behind them, and couldnt put him away. Overeem would smash Carwin. [/quote]
You’re joking, right? Carwin landed ONE semi-flush shot all night, the choppy left that dropped Lesnar. Those “power shots from the top with all his weight behind him” landed on Lesnar’s forearms as he covered his face. I honestly don’t know how we’re arguing this. Carwin has knocked dudes out cold with a straight right from his hand a foot out in front of his face. No torque, no looper, just a quick flick that dropped another 250lb pro fighter. NO ONE ELSE in MMA can do that.
Yes, I’m arguing this at 10:30 on NYE. Gotta work at 7 am and I’m bitter, haha.
[/quote]
Sorry buddy, but i literally JUST rewatched that fight on Unleashed 2 nights ago and Carwin landed at least a dozen clean shots on the ground.
Yes he hits very hard, no i will not say he is the hardest striker in all of MMA. Someone you dont want to get hit by for sure, but i am not ready to say he hits harder than Overeem.