[quote]Jarvan wrote:
[quote]nighthawkz wrote:
[quote]Jarvan wrote:
If you wanna get good at either, don’t lift.
Save your energy, for what matters.
And if you think lifting supplements martial arts, you’re absolutely right, but you’re a complete beginner and most likely don’t know how to utilize lifting for sport.
[/quote]
I’ll chime in here - while I’d agree if he had never lifted before, I think someone who has been lifting for longer periods will have an easier time maintaining the mass and strength he has by still touching weights but less frequently. I once decided to drop weights and suddenly found myself in a lower weight class, with the uncomfortable feeling that I couldn’t do what I used to. Just something to consider.
[/quote]
You felt you lost your capacity to perform in martial arts from not lifting? Not sure what you mean from that last statement.
And of course lifting will help you add mass or size, but is that so pertinent to the OP’s course? He doesn’t specifically state he wants to add, subtract, or maintain mass. And let’s say OP did want to pursue the ambivalent goal of being phenomenal at muay thai, bjj, and get shredded all at once. How often does that actually come to fruition?
I’ll tell ya.
Never.
Either one of two things happen. The trainee gets fried out, or they get injured. BJJ in itself is tremendous work. Muay Thai in itself is tremendous work. And sudden spikes in ‘NEW’ type of workload causes tremendous stress in the body. Especially in the ‘fragile’ ball and socket joint, your hips, and knees.
If you do train, I am almost certain that you know many many practitioners that have shitty knees, shoulders, and hips. And because of that, they can never train full force. What they do do, is talk about physical therapy, get wrapped up like a mummy before rolling, talk about how they’re getting old when they’re only 30, blame their shitty back or hips… And in the end, they doubt their future.
And most of this happens because…
people try to do too much, too soon, with the wrong information… then they raise their fist to the heavens and blame their terrible genetics.
*Please note that I am not at all diminishing the importance of proper lifting.
More likely than not, a trainee will have many imbalances… all of which can be rectified through weight training. However, not all beginners have the money or access to coaches to walk them through these things. With that said, it’s a safer bet for beginners to just have some fun in the sport, first. The rest will follow on its own.
[/quote]
Thanks for the long and thought out post!
I would definitely like to be good/great in what I do, but I know from past experiences to be realistic. So I’ll definitely be planning for the long term instead of expecting to be phenomenal in 6 months, get burnt out and quit.
Currently at 72-73ishKG and about 13-15% BF. (Studying sports science in university so i had the chance to get a legit DEXA scan done on me before. ) As I’m still a total beginner, I wouldn’t expect to be fighting anytime soon (at least not until i’ve had a year or so of training). So I would like to maintain my weight or drop down to 70kg over the course of the year. I believe lifting would help me maintain strength, muscle and work out imbalances. But yes i also do agree that lifting volume should be significantly reduced.
I do think my work capacity is pretty decent though as I used to train twice a day for basketball to a total of about 12 training sessions/week. I’m also studying sports injuries at the moment, so i’ll be sure to take note if i’m experiencing any symptoms of overuse injuries due to training.