[quote]Cheeky_Kea wrote:
[quote]pat wrote:
[quote]Cheeky_Kea wrote:
[quote]forlife wrote:
I think Pat makes a good point. While it’s likely untrue that atheism per se has caused more deaths than religion per se, there’s no question that people have been persecuted and killed by atheists specifically for having religious beliefs. Had they been fellow atheists, they would have been left alone.[/quote]
These people were killed by Communists for having religious beliefs as they veiwed them as being the tool of Western colonialism.
The communnits killed anyone who got in their way.
The range for agnostics and non-religious in China was/is about 40%-60%, atheists about 14%. They were killed as well if found to be “detrimental to socialist reconstruction.”
The Communists under Mao had no Qualms about killing atheist, agnostic, taoist,christian, confucian, non-religious, animist, and Shenist alike.
For political aims…not religious ones.[/quote]
So like historical facts mean nothing? Yes, it’s true it was a political agenda and a political policy to eradicate religion by eradicating the religious. Ergo, they killed believers because they were believers and not atheists…
This is a matter of plain stubborn historical fact. No amount of spin is going to make this not a fact.[/quote]
I got accused of shovelling bullshit a while back…but some of y’alls shovels are about as large as the front scoop on a bulldozer.
Your “historical facts” have more spin from your bias than an f5 tornado.
“Yes, it’s true it was a political agenda and a political policy to eradicate religion by eradicating the religious.”
Yes, this was ONE policy amongst many…not the main overiding policy of the communist party at the time and not specific to the religious…like they were all special and stuff…they tried to get rid of EVERBODY that stood in their way.
Part of your spin seems to be to completely ignore what I just posted about them killing atheists and agnostics and non-religious people indiscriminately along with the religious because they were…
“detrimental to socialist reconstruction.”
Not specifically because they were believers.
You are trying hard to make it sound like a wholly religious persecution. Mao veiwed organised religion as antithetical to the communnist movement…but also veiwed intellectuals, teachers, etc. etc. and a few million other people this way as well…WHO WEREN’T RELIGIOUS.
[quote]pat wrote:
Ergo, they killed believers because they were believers and not atheists…
[/quote]
They killed atheists too…why? because they “believed” in atheism?
That is an absurd statement.
Why would Atheists kill other atheists for religious reasons?
[/quote]
My historical facts? Wasn’t sure I owned them. Apparently history ain’t your forte. Don’t take my word for it, look it up. Go to you local library and just pull up any encyclopedia, seriously do some research. In anti religious campaigns they were targeting relgious people and clergy. Oh fuck why bother. Just do some research before you spout equal opportunity murder horseshit.
You got you piddly revisionist history, my family lived through it ans saw it first hand. Bet your mama never looked down the barrel of a Soviet tank gun that was aimed at her.