[quote]lucasa wrote:
orion wrote:
- Homosexuality, or at least bisexuality once was the cultural norm in all civilized nations.
A cultural achievement, no less…
The historical prevalence is speculative at best. I’m not saying it didn’t exist or that was unacceptable. Analogously we don’t have any hard evidence to explain how the pyramids got built, but your sure the Egyptians were predominantly bi/homosexual. To pass your assertion off as known fact is disingenuous.
And depending on what exact historical context/events your talking about, it could hardly be called a cultural achievement. Personally, I have trouble using sex to define cultural achievement, anything that the vast majority of rabbits do infinitely better than the vast majority of humans precludes it.
- The “sin” part was that the reason homosexuaity is a tad problematic these days is that a few semitic tribes deperately wanted to separate themselves from their neighbours, in part trough strict sexual mores.
So what once was an accepted and even expected part of growing up in Greece or one way of many in Rome became a “sin”.
How about the slaves in Greece and other ancient cultures? Are the Jews the reason slavery is a ‘tad problematic’ today?
Free speech is great that way, if you are programmed by ancient semitic fairy tales , shout it from the mountain tops, so I can smile and back away slowly, preparing to run if I see any hint of foam around the corners of your mouth…
Could you possibly fathom someone having a feeling about homosexuality and knowing it’s right and it having nothing to do with religion? How about knowing it’s wrong?
What makes you think I would get violent about this?
Anybody spending too much time wondering/imagining where other men stick their dicks makes me suspicious…
One could get equally suspicious of an Austrian impugning the practices of Jews two millennia ago because of where the Greeks stuck theirs.[/quote]
I wrote that all the hip cultures did it and that it was seen as a cultural achievement because I think Herodot actually bragged about the fact that an important part of hellenisation was the introduction of pederasty which was more than just gay sex.
I did not say you would get violent about this, it is just that the slight homophobia in our society has religious roots and is by no means rational.
Where else would it come from? Fear or repulsion cannot be the standard norm since it was considered to be completely approbriate by a lot of cultures.