[quote]pushharder wrote:
FYI: Doc Skeptix and I are going gun shopping this weekend!
He will be a first time gun owner and is looking for a gun for self defense. Chime in![/quote]
Many questions before answers:
- Self-defense in what context? Home, car, or carry?
If home and a novice, I lean toward a shotgun. I used to love the Remington 870, but they are having severe quality control issues. I lean toward pumps over semis, too. If his wife intends to use it, I might consider a 20 guage over a 12.
Apartment vs. home is a big issue, too, or at least affects load.
Rural vs. residential is a big issue. I carry a .308 or a .223 with large capacity mags out on the ranch ā but I have bears, cougars, contraband pot growers, and the occasional Mexican drug/human smuggler to deal with.
I also could probably randomly shoot in any direct and not kill anyone, so I take the risk of penetrating rounds.
If car, does he intend to clean the weapon? If not, .357. If so, something .40 or bigger, probably a GLOCK.
Carry? Depends on what he wears. I have mulitple carry guns, ranging from a .45 long colt Schofield recover I strap to my hip (NM being an open carry state), to a 1911 .45, to a .380 I wear with a suit, to a little .38 I put in a pack when mountain climbing.
I wouldnāt conceal carry a GLOCK, however, because the trigger is too easy to press without a holster, IMHO. I like something with a manual safety and double-action for the first shot.
- Notice I did not list a pistol for home self defense. This is because you use a pistol to fight your way to your real weapon, a rifle.
Generally speaking, pistols poke little holes in people until they bleed to death. This takes a little while, and, in the mean time, you have to go fight a dying attacker.
A 12 guage shootgun 000 buck, in contrast shoots 18 or so .38 caliber pellets into someone a far greater veolcities than a 2.5 inch snubby ever thought about. Indeed, itās like emptying a typical .38 revolver 3.5 times into someone ā in one shot.
The result is the threat falls to the ground dead and you have a hell of a mess to clean.
Indeed, any rifle, even the lowly Ruger 10/22 (now an āassault rifleā according to our president ā a suprise to the Cub Scout troop leader who issued us all one for rifelry when I was 8 years old) is probably better than most pistols.