[quote]Demo Dick wrote:
No question, cruelty to animals is not defensible…the question is what is “cruelty?” For some, pet ownership is cruel. For me, it is causing needless suffering, pain, or injury. Then we get into how to define “needless.” It’s a very, very complex argument.[/quote]
I’m of the same mindset as you. Some people are cruel to their pets, sure, but my dog ate like a king, got walked for hours each day, got played with, was loved, had a comfortable home and comfortable places to sleep, he had a very happy life. Can’t see the cruelty in that.
[quote]Demo Dick wrote:
Or starve to death as it ages and can no longer compete for food, or die of untreated and painful disease, or suffer an injury that gets infected and becomes systemic. A “natural” death ends up being pretty miserable for whatever animal we’re talking about. By most peopl’es definitions, nature itself is cruel.[/quote]
Well yeah, but these deaths are very few and far between. It only conceivably would happen with any degree of frequency to natural predators such as lions, and even then they’re likely to be picked off by other lions or something. The disease thing is a fair point, but then it’s impossible to monitor every animal in the world to ensure this doesn’t happen. Even if they die this way, it’s still fair to assume their life hasn’t been subject to the same cruelty as many farmed animals.
[quote]Demo Dick wrote:
I would be interested to see if this is really happening, and if so, is it happening legally? I assume (and we know what that means) that the USDA and FDA would have some kind of prohibition on this. I wouldn’t be okay with it, myself.[/quote]
It happens. You’ll have to excuse me if I don’t go hunting for video proof of it though given it would upset me quite a bit for quite a while. If you’re interested though there is proof out there.
[quote]Demo Dick wrote:
That’s cool. I’m a “live and let live” type of guy. I’m just happy we have enough to eat so we can have a discussion over what we do eat. Many people in the world would love to be able to do that.
[/quote]
I’m very much live and let life until it comes to the point of other people’s rights being violated. For instance, I have no problem with people’s sexual orientations or whatever religious belief they want to hold or their race or anything like that, my problem comes when people take away the rights of other people by being cruel or abusive in some way.
[quote]Demo Dick wrote:
Don’t know anything about it, but I do know how food animals are treated in most of the world. It would be horrifying to most Americans.[/quote]
They slit the animals’ throat and hold it upside down while it bleeds to death. Savage bastards.
Still, not as bad as the Asian countries.