[quote]johnward82 wrote:
SeanT wrote:
johnward82 wrote:
I must admit, while being nieve and unexperienced with the subject at hand, I wonder how skewed the data is regaurding “alcohol kills more people than drugs” simply based on the legality. IE, the pool or alcohol users is going to be signifigantly higher than crack heads due to the legality of the substance. Like I said earlier, I might be incline to try pot if it was legal, but its not, so I dont/wont.
I am looking at the ratio of users:deaths(a year) in the U.K. because I have numbers to that. I’ll fill you in and you must realize that most deaths come from ODes that is from varying qualities and cuts.
Horizon: Is Alcohol worse than Ecstasy?
Heroin: 300,000/700 deaths = 429 users/1 death
Cocaine: 780,000/214 deaths = 3,645 users/1 death
Street Methadone: 33,000/295 deaths = 112 users/1 death
Alkyl Nitrite(legal in UK, Illegal in US): 400,000/0 = 0 deaths
Khat(legal in UK, Illegal in US): 40,000/0 = 0 deaths
Ecstasy: 500,000/27 deaths = 18,519 users/1 death
Anabolic Steroids: 42,000/0 = 0 deaths
Ritalin(Methylphenidate): 40,000/0 = 0 death
LSD: 83,000/0 = 0 death
Solvents: 30,000/50-60( Bag falls over head, but solvents cause irreversible damage to nerves and organs) = 500-600/1 death
Cannabis: 3,000,000/1 death(I think the death was later confirmed not to be cannabis) = 3,000,000/1 death(if a true death)
Amphetamines: 430,000/35 = 12,286/1 death
Benzos: 100,000/406 = 246/1 death
Ketamine: 100,000/1 = 100,000/1 death
Tobacco: 10,000,000/114,000 = 88/1 death
Alcohol: 40,000,000/40,000 = 1,000/1 death
Then I calculated(I understand that many people are poly drug users these are not super accurate)
All users and deaths other than Tobacco + Alcohol:
5,877,916 users/ 1738 deaths =
3,382users/1 death
All users of Tobacco + alcohol:
50,000,000 users/154,000 deaths
325 Users/1 death
So Tobacco + alcohol kill 10x more people
Heroin is non-toxic, so if legalized(I am not saying legalize it, I’m just saying), the amount of deaths would drop DRASTICALLY. Most drugs if legalized(again, I do NOT support this), the amount of deaths would drop due to clean products and not having to guess the strength.
Thats good, and I can see the point, but then should you not compare that to deaths from say, alcohol posioning? I still think, and maybe it is just a stretch, that we are not comparing apples to apples. Your deaths from drugs come from “immediate” OD where no one has died from tobacco in the short term. Its like comparing long term death to short term death isn’t it?
Not that I really dissagree, but for the sake of argument.
[/quote]
I understand exactly what you are saying, it’s not very accurate, but its a nice perspective on things.
Also, according to the BBC, Alcohol withdraw is worse than heroin.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/health/conditions/mental_health/drugs_use.shtml#what_are_the_symptoms?__
Physical addiction
It’s ironic that through films such as Trainspotting quite a lot of people feel that they understand the physical effects of withdrawal from heroin. They rightly see it as an unpleasant and difficult experience - and a good reason not to experiment with it.
The irony is that alcohol has much worse and more dangerous withdrawal effects. It’s possible, but very rare, for someone experiencing heroin withdrawal to need to be admitted to hospital, while someone who is physically addicted to alcohol should not attempt to stop using it without consulting a doctor.
Again, as with psychological dependence, the length and severity of withdrawal differs according to the drug, how much has been taken and for how long.
For most addicts, their problem is a mixture of both physical and psychological aspects. There are some instances when it’s difficult to distinguish between the two.
The stimulants cocaine and amphetamine are classic examples of this - people coming down after using these drugs feel very low and lack energy. When they take cocaine, they feel very high and use up lots of energy. Their feelings afterwards could be partly because of feeling tired and adjusting to a normal mood again, but there are other theories that suggest these feelings are because the body is re-establishing its chemical balance.