Doctors Planning Exit Under Obamacare

[quote]Aragorn wrote:

In other words you went straight to ideology without thinking about the facts in front of you and what they mean.
.[/quote]

lol, yup.

As for doctor’s salaries:

As I waited to get my vasectomy I looked around the waiting room and realized my doctor will either have to examine the penis and/or stick his finger in the ass of all the people in that room…

The way a couple people smelled, that doctor deserved to get paid MORE than he was, by at least 30%.

I can only imagine what the typical day at the OBGYN, podiatrist or proctologist is like. Vial, putrid people live in this world, and doctors have to cup their nuts, and treat their yeast infections, boils, rashes, bed sores, bot flies, and impactions…

Do you know what a compaction entails?

FML, these people deserve every penny they make, even if they don’t know what a precise macro breakdown should be.

Why won’t these fucking doctors just work for free? Selfish greedy assholes imo.

[quote]UtahLama wrote:

[quote]Zeppelin795 wrote:

[quote]dmaddox wrote:

[quote]Zeppelin795 wrote:

First of all schooling in this country is way too expensive.

[/quote]

Lets tackle this, and I will try to make it simple. Zep have you noticed that every topic you talk about is too expensive, and those topics are mostly paid by the government? When the government gets into an industry and starts allowing people to borrow at low interest rates, or giving people money the prices start to go through the roof. Healthcare (Medicare and Medicaid), College (Pel Grants, loans, and many other scholarships), Housing (FHA, Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac), and the list could go on and on. It is called INFLATION. Price INFLATION will always be higher than wage inflation. This is why the middle class is disappearing.

Do you understand?
[/quote]
Wow, since when do the costs of government run healthcare sectors outpace those of the private sectors?[/quote]

When the gubment pays for people to go to med school…you realize that is an enormous bill right? That would now be a built in cost.[/quote]

You mean like the wars?

[quote]UtahLama wrote:

[quote]Zeppelin795 wrote:

[quote]Aragorn wrote:

[quote]Zeppelin795 wrote:

First of all schooling in this country is way too expensive. Secondly I can’t say that we have the best doctors in the world. They are woefully ignorant of nutrition. I don’t care if they want to make some money just curious what their counterparts in the world make and what their schooling costs them? Is that a sin?[/quote]

Well, this is a first. I completely agree schooling is too expensive. And they are–generally speaking, not without numerous exceptions–ignorant of actual good nutrition.

But 1) being ignorant of nutrition is not enough for me to mark doctors down in grade. This is because they work almost exclusively with the clinical crowd. You don’t expect a strength coach to know the in’s and out’s of clinical post-surgery physical therapy. That’s not the population they work with. And that’s the reason we have physical therapists–to fill the niche created by the fact the strength coach has hundreds of other responsibilities in training healthy athletes of many different sports. Likewise, this is the reason we have clinical nutritionists–because doctors are busy diagnosing diseases, doing surgery, and everything else. The sheer volume of knowledge they have to cram into their heads just to do clinical diagnosis and treatments of all common diseases is almost unbelievable.

Don’t get me wrong, I’m not happy that they suck at nutrition. I despise it. However, giving them proper grounding in nutrition would constitute a very significant burden of time, on the order of at least an additional year to year and a half of school with much, much more debt to pay for that time. It would also increase their workload, and that is why they have the clinical nutrition people in the first place. It is a needed niche to have a specialist by virtue of the vast pool of knowledge to keep up with. Same reason we have pharmacists in hospitals–whatever your stance on pharma is, there’s too much literature and work to put it also on the MD.

Also our definition of nutrition is different than theirs. Clinical nutritionists also suck at nutrition outside the hospital zone, but that’s another story. Again–different populations, different areas of focus. The kind of nutrition needed in acute disease or clinical deficiency is much different than the kind needed to function optimally at a world class performance level.

2)The rate of growth of medical knowledge is exponential at this point. There were roughly 1 million medical articles published in 2012 (not newspapers, medical journals and science articles). There is no way in hell a doctor can keep up with areas outside his expertise, the volume is too much. That is why I don’t blame them for being on the outs regarding nutrition.

It also has less than 80 million people…why do you not get that things that work there, will not work here?

Macro/micro[/quote]
Why? Because they have less people? Don’t they have a much smaller pool of money to draw from but still get the job done?

[quote]Aragorn wrote:

[quote]Zeppelin795 wrote:

Since nutrition is the key to good health I think it is something doctors should know. But I guess since Big pharma doesn’t make money off of it, nutrition will never be a focus. Viva la profit motive! Also I would say it does downgrade the level of respect our doctors should get. They are supposed to help you but their ignorance hurts you.

I’m for whatever benefits the majority and if that means cutting the salary of doctors- so be it! But we agree that schooling here is ridiculous.

As far as Germany is concerned they have some of the highest forms of government assistance but have not been greatly affected by the crash in the Eurozone. Especially compared to most of the other countries. This goes against conservative economics, just like the high cost of schooling and healthcare.
[/quote]

So essentially you just ignored the entire sourced, data driven post I just made and went to general talking points without a hint of understanding why the cost of education and insurance drives healthcare costs up or why I say doctors pay should not be cut. In particular–that if you graduate near half a fucking million dollars in debt and half to pay a blue collar salary every year on top of that then you NEED the high rate of pay to pay back the debt you owe and insurance.

You also ignored the fact that I am not necessarily against doctors wages being lowered AS LONG AS their debt burden and insurance burden decreases by at least as much so that we can maintain a high quality of talent in the pool.

You also completely ignored the absolutely obvious correlation between research work growth and lack of time to become experts in nutrition ON TOP OF everything else they need. What part about 10,000 diseases and 1 million medical articles published last year did you miss?

In addition you also completely ignored the fact that we already HAVE nutritionists at hospitals and healthcare centers. Their job is SPECIFICALLY nutrition. So nutrition is not ignored, even though docs do not understand as much as we wish they did. There needs to be better integration of the two, but that is not to say that doctors need to spend another $100,000-$150,000 on an addition year to year and a half of school to focus solely on nutrition. Yes there does need to be better nutrition practice, but you are ignoring the reasons for the difficulty by invoking the magical “big pharma and profit motive” blanket terms.

In other words you went straight to ideology without thinking about the facts in front of you and what they mean.

I won’t waste another long time typing out a well reasoned post for you again. Thanks for warning me.[/quote]
The medical field is driven by the pharmaceutical industry. They cannot make money off of recommending nutrition so it isn’t taught. it makes little difference that there are nutritionists in the hospital as they are given a back seat to pharmaceuticals.

Since nutrition is of primary importance in the treatment and prevention of diseases why shouldn’t it be given a higher priority? Isn’t the job of doctors to help make you well?

Your whole premise is off so all your arguments that follow will be as well. To claim that lack of time on something so critically important is an excuse. That is one of your arguments? Why should I take you seriously when post stuff like this?

Please do not waste your time typing out delusions as you are wasting both our time.

seems relevant…

[quote]countingbeans wrote:
seems relevant…

[/quote]
More like cliche.

[quote]UtahLama wrote:

[quote]Zeppelin795 wrote:

[quote]countingbeans wrote:

[quote]Zeppelin795 wrote:

Curious what American doctors make compared to the rest of the world?[/quote]

What would it matter?

[/quote]
Interesting to note. To see what the differences are so you can trace the psychology.[/quote]

So you are surprised that somebody who works their asses off to get good grades from Jr. High on through college, JUST so they can get into med school and spend 10’s of thousands of dollars …JUST so they can go intern in a hospital for peanuts…might want to make some money after they are out?

SHOCKING.

We have the best doctors in the world, and they are paid accordingly…if you are jealous, go to med school.[/quote]

*Hundreds of thousands in med school.

Sorry, I don’t think a lot of people understand how long it takes before the typical doctor is in the black after school.

[quote]CroatianRage wrote:

Sorry, I don’t think a lot of people understand how long it takes before the typical doctor is in the black after school.[/quote]

Yeah, and some in this thread don’t have a single clue as to how much work the typical doctor does to earn the salary they earn that goes to pay off school for the most part for the better part of a lifetime.

[quote]countingbeans wrote:

[quote]CroatianRage wrote:

Sorry, I don’t think a lot of people understand how long it takes before the typical doctor is in the black after school.[/quote]

Yeah, and some in this thread don’t have a single clue as to how much work the typical doctor does to earn the salary they earn that goes to pay off school for the most part for the better part of a lifetime. [/quote]

Next time the 3AM ER doc is putting someone’s face back together after a DUI car wreck we can all insult their lack of awareness of vitamins and minerals.

[quote]CroatianRage wrote:

[quote]countingbeans wrote:

[quote]CroatianRage wrote:

Sorry, I don’t think a lot of people understand how long it takes before the typical doctor is in the black after school.[/quote]

Yeah, and some in this thread don’t have a single clue as to how much work the typical doctor does to earn the salary they earn that goes to pay off school for the most part for the better part of a lifetime. [/quote]

Next time the 3AM ER doc is putting someone’s face back together after a DUI car wreck we can all insult their lack of awareness of vitamins and minerals.
[/quote]

And after you do that, I’ll ask him to take a 30-40% pay cut as well.

[quote]VTBalla34 wrote:

[quote]Bauber wrote:
I am seeing more come out of my check each month to pay for those who don’t and aren’t. Sounds fair… Not.[/quote]

This sounds like its on the same level of bullshit that you were spewing in the Red State vs. Blue State violent crime discussion, which you conveniently never posted in after I posted the actual statistics.

So please explain to us how your tax burden has changed over the past 5 years? That would be especially strange considering the lack of change in tax brackets and SS/Medicare deductions. Unless of course you would have us to believe you make $500k+ per year lol
[/quote]

I didn’t respond to you because you came at me like a fucking dickhead and didn’t link anything that proved your point, so I just let it be. And the thread you posted once and then said don’t even bother responding because you wouldn’t be posting there again? What happened to that tough guy? And blue states may have been he wrong designation, but blue cities paints the picture better.

Here is a map. All the blue correlates with HIGH crime area. Now get off my nuts.

You have no idea how much I make per year and is pretty brave of you to assume. You have not seen your taxes increase? That is funny every single person around me has. IN the form of insurance premiums paid through work. Maybe I need to live in your world where blue states have low crime and taxes aren’t increasing. And btw I was born in Baltimore and lived there for quite some time. It is a cesspool.

Blue Cross sent me a check for 9.38 because they didn’t use 80% of premiums for health care because of Obamacare. So make sure you divide that by 12 and put it in your zero based budget. I think they gave me like 6 dollars last year too. Anyone know any good mutual funds?

[quote]CroatianRage wrote:
Blue Cross sent me a check for 9.38 because they didn’t use 80% of premiums for health care because of Obamacare. So make sure you divide that by 12 and put it in your zero based budget. I think they gave me like 6 dollars last year too. Anyone know any good mutual funds?[/quote]

It probably cost more in admin & overhead to send you that check than you put in your account. lol

[quote]countingbeans wrote:

[quote]CroatianRage wrote:
Blue Cross sent me a check for 9.38 because they didn’t use 80% of premiums for health care because of Obamacare. So make sure you divide that by 12 and put it in your zero based budget. I think they gave me like 6 dollars last year too. Anyone know any good mutual funds?[/quote]

It probably cost more in admin & overhead to send you that check than you put in your account. lol[/quote]

Well as far as I see it Obamacare has saved me a little over 78 cents a month on health insurance. I know that for positive because I put it into a calculator. Nevermind the fact that in the 4 years I’ve had to pay my own insurance my premium has gone up 18 dollars per month.

[quote]Bauber wrote:
I didn’t respond to you because you came at me like a fucking dickhead and didn’t link anything that proved your point, so I just let it be.

[/quote]

First off I didn’t come at YOU like anything…I saw an ongoing debate on a public forum where one side was claiming that the other side had more crime, and vice versa, and that smelled fishy to me… Since none of the participants seemed interested in pointing any actual data to support their claims, you know because conjecture and personal anecdote is soooo much more reliable, I wanted to see what the facts were to support either side. I was genuinely curious. I didn’t post that so you could respond to me, I posted it so the people that were interested in engaging in that debate could have something to reference. People that don’t have their minds already made up about waht the answer is going to be before looking at actual data tend to use that data to either reinforce their position or to possibly give themselves the opportunity to back out gracefully. You know that scientific method that alludes so many…At least you did that, but I am always hoping that someone when presented with facts contrary to their argument might atually give a “shit I was wrong, my bad…lets grab a beer”…that notion is laughable on this website though.

[quote]

And blue states may have been he wrong designation, but blue cities paints the picture better.[/quote]

Well, genius, we weren’t talking about blue cities were we? What you are trying to do now is a tactic known as “moving the goal posts”. I did not talk about cities because the conversation was not about cities. It was a conversation in a thread about Stand Your Ground, which is a state wide law (a couple guys seemed to have missed that point, so you at least aren’t alone) between you and FightinIrish, telling him to keep his criminals and rapists in the northern blue states so you and your southern red states could enjoy your utopian crime free lifestyle. Here was your quote in case you forgot:

[quote]Bauber wrote:

Good keep all the criminals up there too. We enjoy your states being infested with them, so they don’t come here.[/quote]

[quote]

You have no idea how much I make per year and is pretty brave of you to assume. [/quote]

You claim to be 27 and in law school so yeah I am pretty confident in my brave assumption, unless you are a liar (not unreasonable). Perhaps you are one of those white unicorn law school students who also have a bashing side gig you operate while not under 60 hours of case law per week. Or maybe you just graduated and got hired at a firm putting you in the top 2% (again, a rarity). if so then congraulations man!! I love seeing people doing well at a young age. But I was also using statistics (you know, those scary facts) that only 2% or whatever the upper cutoff was actually have seen a tax increase (why that is the same cutoff for Mensa!!)…so yeah, I stick by my assumption…

I’m just going to post this so everyone can read it and let it sink in for a minute. I’m not going to post any "LOL"s or "hahahhahahahahhaha"s or point out how ridiculously off the reservation a statement like this would be. Nor am I going to explain to you the difference between a “tax” and other deductions that come out of your paycheck, because only an idiot would require such a simple distinction be made to them. Nor am I going to point out the fact that insurance premiums have been skyrocketing long before Obama was taking all your guns and precious commodities to hand out to the ghetto boys that support him and to actually attribute it to him is quite a dumb rock to stand on in the rising waters of intelligence. Nah, I’m not going to do any of that …

[quote]
Maybe I need to live in your world where blue states have low crime and taxes aren’t increasing. [/quote]

Yes, you should try living in the real world and not the one you’ve made up.

[quote]CroatianRage wrote:

[quote]countingbeans wrote:

[quote]CroatianRage wrote:

Sorry, I don’t think a lot of people understand how long it takes before the typical doctor is in the black after school.[/quote]

Yeah, and some in this thread don’t have a single clue as to how much work the typical doctor does to earn the salary they earn that goes to pay off school for the most part for the better part of a lifetime. [/quote]

Next time the 3AM ER doc is putting someone’s face back together after a DUI car wreck we can all insult their lack of awareness of vitamins and minerals.
[/quote]
Nutrition has to do with prevention and treatment of disease not acute injuries, which western medicine has done a good job with.