The problem with this line of thought is that you don’t explain “compared to what”? How many additional deaths would result from your particular society allowing more freedom and encouraging people to be responsible? I couldn’t say for a place like the UK, but a comparison of Florida and California in the USA doesn’t really paint a favorable picture of authoritarian policies.
People are also fleeing these places in numbers unseen in my lifetime. Deaths aren’t the only meaningful metric, far from it in fact. Especially when our leaders are not particularly forthcoming about the nature of these deaths, seemingly having chalked up a lot of people who died with COVID as COVID deaths.
Most delusional people will tell you they’re not delusional, but I don’t feel like any of my observations are untethered to reality. All we need to do is look across the pond to the UK or across the big pond to Australia to see what more developed versions of these policies look like, along with the willingness of people to go right along with the most extreme measures as long as its done under the pretense of public health.
The fact that Democrats say we need MORE authoritarianism at this stage of the pandemic with the threat profile presently presented is rather telling. That’s why I don’t find the poll results particularly surprising, as it hashes with simple policy and rhetoric observations you can make here in the USA.
Taking a step back, this is all entirely in-line with the line of thinking that goes into many liberal policies. You and I have dramatically different ideas about gun control and self-defense laws, for instance, and even entertaining the idea that UK gun policy is a net negative on society is treated as a beyond the pale disregard for human life by so many people.
In fact, many people seem quite proud of their do-nothing gun control policy in the UK, having given away their rights for little more than assuaging the feelings of people with irrational fears. All you need to do is compare the before and after crime rates in the UK and see how ineffective they were.
This is the danger of the pretense of ostensibly compassionate policies couched in good intentions. Every totalitarian in history has come couched in good intentions, and then went on to oversee varying levels of social and cultural arson among their people. After the policies fail spectacularly, they all went on to do all kinds of horrible things once they eliminated any sort of resistance through laws like gun control, speech control and heavy-handed coercion.
Back to the USA, where we’ve staved that sort of thing off for over 200 years, we are blessed with enough people who will entertain the possibility that doing nothing at all will play out better over time than whatever the next vast government boondoggle will be.
Besides, how will you know when you’re being governed by incompetent fools with no tools in their toolbox besides lies and heavy-handed authoritarian policies?
If the presence of incompetent fools, authoritarian policies and abysmal outcomes isn’t a big enough warning, when would someone like you find it alarming?