[quote]Professor X wrote:
makkun wrote:
Lorisco,
Lorisco wrote:
…
How is sexual preference a minority status? How would someone know to persecute them if they didn’t say they were gay? How the fucking hell can you compare people who have struggled in this country to be accepted as just being human to a sexual preference choice?
I can’t choose to be a different skin color or from a different race, by gays can and do choose their lifestyle preferences. Comparing the two is totally offensive. I would like you to go to any predominately Latino part of town and spout out that shit. Then explain to them what you just did to me as they are kicking the living shit out of you!
I think you misunderstand the term minority yourself: “a part of a population differing from others in some characteristics and often subjected to differential treatment”
http://www.webster.com/cgi-bin/dictionary?sourceid=Mozilla-search&va=Minority
Anyone can be part of a minority (women, Christians, Texans, nomads, Martians), just depending on the socio-economic context. To state that gay people are not a minority is therefore a misinterpretation.
To state that homosexuality is a choice is problematic as well, as - I think ZEB has pointed that out in a huge thread on the topic once - this has not been proven; neither is it proven that it is purely biological. So that bit of your argument is weak as well, as you have cannot really verify your statement.
But the part of your argument that is really disappointing is that you do not seem to acknowledge that people have been persecuted for what they are - whether they had a choice in their otherness or not. Homosexuals have been subjected to violence, discrimination and were put into concentration camps just like jewish people (a religious choice, not a biological classification either). The fact that there were (are) enough assholes around them to make their lives miserable is what makes minority groups comparable - whether their otherness is based on choice or not.
So even if it were their choice, gay people have a right not to be prosecuted, which any true freedom-loving democratic humanist should defend.
Makkun
You obviously haven’t read his other posts.
That is all I will add to this thread at this point. Debating with Lorisco is a waste of energy and internet bandwidth.[/quote]
Ayyy…I forgot about the gay marriage thread, I already learned this lesson.