I debated replying to this post for quite awhile simply because I am a school teacher (with dreams of teaching at the college level), and I didn’t want to respond out of anger for being indirectly called a ‘fool’ for my chosen profession.
I’ll start with the potentially sensitive pay issue. I’ll try to frame it this way: differences between group A (teachers, and I’m assuming policemen, firefighters, etc.) and group B (lawyers, doctors, etc.) is that while all professions make comparable starting salaries, the potential for greater salaries is MUCH greater with group B professions. Group B WILL eventually see 6 figures in their paycheck. Group A NEVER will. With all this said, while I’ll generally agree that teachers are underpaid, it’s all relative. Teachers definitely make enough money to have a decent living. Even when I get to the college level, my salary will probably not be that much greater from teaching in high school. I’m inclined to think that young teachers nowadays know what they’re getting into with regards to their pay. I know I did, so I won’t/don’t complain much about my individual salary. Also, average statistics, while factual, don’t necessarily reflect reality. For example, I worked in Denver last year, and between rent & utilities, I paid $635/month. I now work as a part-time (.8) teacher in Long Island, and despite being .8, make almost the same amount as last year. Rent & utilities is now $870/month. Cost of living as well as average salary, varies greatly depending on where you live, at least for a teacher. As far as benefits go, they vary greatly depending on the school district, and probably range from comparable to the benefits of other professions, to being greater/lesser.
Now moving onto the vacation times of teachers (I mentioned this in another thread). Some people seem to assume that it’s nice for teachers to get all the time off that they do, and that they actually DO go on vacation (do no work) during that time. Of all the teachers I know, I’m only aware of a minority that actually do no work during that time. The ones that do vacation are usually married and have a nice combined income with their spouse. Most teachers I know, especially young, single ones, either work second jobs (coaching, bartending, sales, etc. - all year round, I may add) or are attending graduate school, which is exactly what I do every summer. Heck, let’s look at this week, which I have off for winter break. I visited the folks for 3 days over the weekend. When I returned to my apartment, I’ve done nothing but do work related to either school or graduate school. In fact, I’m actually going into school tomorrow to do even more work. Furthermore, teachers regularly bring their work home with them. Not occasionally, but regularly.
Also, I’ve seen a few posters mention that most teachers are terrible or that VERY few people can teach. While I don’t necessarily agree, with these statements, obviously there ARE poor teachers out there, just as there are great ones. If you think about it, this idea applies to ALL professions. There are good/great (insert profession here) everywhere, just as there are poor ones. Be as honest as possible, how good are YOU at your own profession? Average? Above average? Below average? Regardless of the answer, what are YOU doing to become better at your profession? Graduate classes? Seeking advice from colleagues? Reading books? Nothing?
Also, what constitutes a good teacher from a bad teacher? This is a very difficult question that I suspect deserves its own thread, and would get a few dozen different answers. I know that caring about the students & your job is not enough, because my experience in Denver last year screams otherwise. Another question I have is that of the teachers you’ve had in your life that you consider ‘poor’, did you learn anything from them? I found a few teachers to be poor in college, but I will admit that I learned quite a bit from them.
Personally, I think changes in the train of thought that dominate society nowadays have contributed greatly to the effectiveness of teachers, in a negative way. My dad and his peers will share stories of ‘the ruler’, and how a call home to the parents meant punishment of some sort. Nowadays, if I used ‘the ruler’, I would get sued (and probably lose), and when I call home, either the parent is supportive of either me or his/her child. Usually, no severe punishment is involved.
I hope this post made at least a little bit of sense. I would be curious as to Shug’s thoughts on all the above, since he used to be a teacher. Where are you Shugart?