[quote]Mascherano wrote:
[quote]Edevus wrote:
FightinIrish26, I will say it one more time and not again, because I’m tired of this.
The problem is that the economical system/welfare system of many European countries is NOT prepared to hold this. The system can not sustain such large amount of leechers. Why is it so hard to understand for you?
What is going through your head to not understand this at all. This is not about races, as you implied yesterday, it’s about the system not being able to sustain people who multiply their numbers and don’t work or have any education.
For many years, public healthcare has been having benefits and this money has been invested in building new hospitals, getting new material in, research, etc. Why? Because 100 worked to maintain 200 who didn’t (unemployed, children, retired, disabled, etc.). Now many healthcare systems are close to bankrupt. Why? Because 100 are working to maintain 2000 and this is not working. This number of leechers is increasing due to high birthrate, but their education level is still very low and many don’t even try to look for a job. There are other causes (baby boom people starting to retire or increase in life expectancy) of course.
Do you understand now? Or should we start with how healthcare works in most European countries and slowly move on from there? Like, how illegal immigrants got free medicines (many Spanish counties are starting to put limits to this to avoid collapse)?
You have NOT have anything similar in Jersey because your education, healthcare and welfare system work much differently. So stop bringing up things that are not related, like “race” or “this is happening all the time in USA” when it’s not.
[/quote]
As an American, it is difficult to understand the social system of European countries, as that would require research that is out of my scope of interest right now. But rather than asking if we understand, you should just try to better explicate what you mean and the system itself.
But i do believe I understand the gist of the problem you speak of (assuming you are conveying it correctly, again, I’m not about to verify). Aside from seeing this as a problem of higher a birth rate of these welfare leeches, couldn’t you also say this is a problem is a diminished workforce that can’t sustain the social welfare system? Or perhaps its time to stop making healthcare free and charge folks in the grand ol’ American way?
How do you guys fund your welfare system? Through taxes?
[/quote]
I’ll try to give a quick review of how Spanish welfare system works, but your last lines are right on spot.
A Spanish worker receives two different deductions from its salary, IRPF (Taxes) and SS (Social Security). The IRPF part is variable, depending the salary, social situation (children, etc.) and other values and it goes from 0% to 43%. We’ll forget about this now.
Then we have the SS value, which is fixed (if I remember correctly at 4.7%-5.6%) and this money goes to fund the SS. Then the company also has to pay to SS depending the salary of the worker. I think this value was around 22%.
This SS money goes, mostly, to fund the healthcare system.
In theory, this should work as follows. If I’m worker or I’m maintained by a worker (non-working wife, children, retired parents, etc.) I got the right to “free” healthcare. So I can go for free to the doctor as many times as I want. I also got free specialists, which includes psychologists, but not dentists.
The medicines get a discount (50% I think it was) and this remaining 50% is paid by the healthcare system. So, all this doctors, medicines discounts, etc. is paid by this SS money.
What was the worry? That the population was aging and the workforce started to diminish and, while the health system economy was in great state, it was better to add more taxpayers. Also, we had the “boom” of building which required tons of workforce, so the doors were open wide for immigrants.
What happened? First, too many came. It’s not that many men came, it’s that it was probably not expected that for every man, there would be a wife, lots of children, cousins, parents, etc. Secondly, their integration, for any reason, was not as good as expected and not all started to work. Some did great (Chinese, Turkish, Romanians, etc.) but some others, mostly Africans, due to poor education, got stuck and were thrown into poverty…with lots of children to feed.
What happens? The population ages, lives longer and all those “taxpayers” that were expected, have become people that need to be supported.
Throwing some random numbers now, Spain had 100 workers to support 200 non-workers and the idea was to end with 250 workers to support 350 non-workers (mostly, all those people born in the 50s and 60s and that will retire soon), but due to different things, now we got 150 workers supporting 700 non-workers.
It didn’t work and the system that was supposed to be very nice, is being abused and milked. A guy without education or job is having tons of children. These children are coming to this world in public hospitals, attended by doctors and nurses. Then they get free baby bottles, diapers, medicines and medical attention. And the guy is not working.
The system was designed to get an influx of immigrants, who would quickly take jobs and have children that they could sustain…but it didn’t work.
And now the local governments need to backpedal and start blocking the support because they can’t afford it.
I hope you can understand now. There’s lots of immigrants in Spain who work very hard and they marry with Spanish people or with their own, but they send their children to school and do their best. These guys are most welcome, really. But the ones who just don’t do anything outnumber them and this has to be stopped somehow.