[quote]FattyFat wrote:
[quote]ajj6603 wrote:
Surgery I had sorta mimics an ACL repair but of the wrist. I was in casts and splints for 12 weeks. After than it was just getting my ROM back…and try to use the hand for daily living. At 5 months I started at 2lb dumbells and worked my way up to 15lbs (wrist curls, biscep/tricp…basically any movements I could do with a dumbbell…I mean i took it REAL slow…
[/quote]
OK, good to know.
[quote]ajj6603 wrote:
I was told to forget about heavy weights but normal weights and fitness would be just fine. Sadly I still dont know what “normal” is since a 300lb bench was normal for me. Also, I was very atrophed when I had that surgery since I was misdiagnosed for soo long…my arm was all bone. I figured this is why its taking forever for me.
[/quote]
That’s what I wanted to ask next. Did your surgeon specify what he meant by 90%? 90% in relation to what?
[quote]ajj6603 wrote:
Im about 15 months post op. I wake up pretty cracky in the mornings over the tfcc area and there is some slight swelling here and there. All the popping, cracking and snapping is on the tfcc side but it doesnt hurt…just annoying.
[/quote]
I’m wondering about the swelling part. I’d like to know if the swelling you describe is a result of irritated connective tissue or irritated bone.
[quote]ajj6603 wrote:
They do these repairs super tight…I still feel I have to crack my hand for relief.
[/quote]
This I know from personal experience. The more stable my wrist got, the less I had to crack my hand for relief.
What movement do you perform to crack your wrist for relief?
Ulnar flexion?
Radial flexion?
Palmar flexion?
Dorsal flexion?
[quote]ajj6603 wrote:
I think my repair is “fine” since im not in severe pain and pushing my hand on my wrist every 5 mins…but there is nooo way this is 90% of normalcy which concerns me. Im still working mainly with dumbbells…up to 30lb curls, dumbbell press…stuff like that. My wrist actually feels the best when I work out…but again not normal. I also stretch between sets which does help.
[/quote]
In my opinion, your last statement is a good sign. That used to be the same with my wrist after having fallen on my hand 6 months post-op. More on that farther below.
[quote]ajj6603 wrote:
Im wondering what your dr told you after your surgery…since it sounds like he just repaired a ligament…but yet you still notice a difference.
[/quote]
My surgeon didn’t repair the ligament, he reconstructed it by using a tendon from my palmaris muscle of the same hand. So, as with your case, my biomechanics had be altered by the reconstruction. Only I got an autograft, whereas they used an allograft on you (cadaver tendon).
Sadly, my doc just spared 5 mins to recommend a physiotherapist to me. I wasn’t told about the big impact a proper rehab has. At that time, I totally underestimated it.
[quote]ajj6603 wrote:
My surgeon told me he does these ALL the time and how i will be FINE and to have some faith…lol right. Then he started mentioning a few high profile athelets he has done these too and they are back at the top of their game…
[/quote]
More the reason you should consult him, again. Just make sure to convince him that you sensibly eased back into training. And have a detailed breakdown of your training ready. It’s important your training can be ruled out as the cause for impeding / slowing your recovery.
[quote]ajj6603 wrote:
So when you fell on your reapaired hand i take it you didnt distrub the repair… Did you sprain it and there is more laxity? Im still pretty stiff in the mornings…but it goes away.
[/quote]
You bet it did!
-
I got some minor ulnar-sided swelling and ulnar flexion always resulted in annoying and uncomfortable clicking.
-
my wrist lost stability, got more lax
-
loaded dorsal flexion (as with a push-up) hurt a lot: ulnar-sided and dorsal-sided, at the stem of the wrist
-
generally, pressing exercises made matters worse - unless I maintained a straigh wrist (avoided dorsal flexion)
-
actually, the only things that didn’t aggravate my wrist were exercises with the force applying straight into the forearm: push-ups on fists, maintaining a straight wrist during squats, pressing exercises etc. Curls, lateral raises, triceps exercises weren’t feasible.
-
and, as with you, my wrist felt most stable during training. No wonder, the pumped-up forearm muscles provide temporary stability by reducing empty space created by lax ligaments.
I tried a lot.
-
at first, I tried laying off training (which was hard). Didn’t do jack.
-
then, I took it up with the surgeon. He ordered another MRI done which - surprise! - showed nothing of significance. According to the MRI my wrist was perfectly fine. There you go
Of course, the doc palpated my wrist and couldn’t deny that something was out of whack. But short of another arthroscopy - which he strongly advised against - he couldn’t offer more counsel.
-
so I read and researched until I found an interesting article outlining how loaded eccentrics can improve tendinopathies. At first I was only marginally interested, but the premise sounded worth a try. I surmised that maybe the tendon graft became irritated. So, I did eccentric wrist curls, with my forearm propped on a bench I kneeled before and using my free arm for the concentric portion of the wrist curl. 2-3 weeks later, I was mostly pain-free. The clicking subsided. If I had to guesstimate, I’d say that my wrist just clicked in 1 of 100 ulnar flexions. I still felt some dorsal pressure during heavy pressing exercises, but that was about it. Still, I took my sweet time, about 6 months, before reincorporating stuff like curls into my training. And even then, only moderately. But all in all, I was able to pull and push a lot, again. Still, the biomechanics had been altered and with every pressing I did, I maintained the straight wrist - no exceptions. I was too happy with the level of functionality I got back. Additionally, I modified all exercises to maintain neutral or at least neutral-pronated grips. The more neutral you go with your wrist (thumb pointing upwards), the more force is distributed along the radius which usually can bear a lot more with TFCC-plagued people (barring an plus/minus ulna/radius variants).
Still, doing stuff like triceps pushdowns wasn’t doable. But I was able to work my way up to standing unilateral 165 lbs dumbbell overhead press for a good 8-10 reps at a bodyweight of about 190 lbs in 2009 (can’t do that anymore because I fucked up my shoulders big time, but that’s another story).
I also worked my way up to a 190 lbs unilateral dumbbell row for a good 4-6 reps. But my wrist didn’t like that much
Also, you might want to consider your nutrition. I have a history of not eating enough to compensate the stress I put on my body with my training (both heavy lifting and lots of cardio). I’ve once read in a study that your body ‘prefers’ to utilize nutritional protein to repair muscles over connective tissue. Which makes sense: muscle tissue is well vascularized whereas connective tissue is avascular in comparison.
So, at the risk of sounding like a broken record:
- have your wrist re-evaluated by your surgeon
- if your surgeon can’t help you, consult another one
- if lax ligaments contribute to your symptoms, consider prolotherapy
[/quote]
So this clicking you got…was it over the ulnar head…tfcc area? When I feel like i need to pop my wrist…which is many many many times a day. I apply just a slight amount of pressure to my pisaform (bone on palm side)…this area feels lax to me…but again…stable (doesnt feel like its falling out of place.) For my repair they usually use the same tendon they did for you…but since I am female…I was told the tendon wasnt long enough…so they used the same tendon but from a male cadaver…hey at least they knew that…one less thing that could go wrong…
Im a bit hesitant on the Prolotherapy right now…Im just to afraid of anyone messing with my wrist. I looked up the eccentric wrist curls. Thanks I will try that…i have done numerous wrist and reverse wrist curls but not eccentric. You said within a few weeks you saw a noticable difference? HOw many sets where you doing and how often? Also where you doing any other lifting / activites / sports? I want to give this a fair shot so let me know your entire program. Thanks for your help!