[quote]Ken St.Mich wrote:
Hahahaha I had a blast reading this.
Pepper spray? For a little girl?
Take a big step back and literally ah no forget about it. Look at the situation.
You have a couple of girls attacking a girl.
While I don�´t know what was outside the camera picture, I doubt there were others involved. The article didn�´t mention it.
Concerning the training and attributes a security guard should have, I did not say that they are all trained or just strong.
Unfortunately not. But I expect it from a security guard. Otherwise he puts himself at risk and can�´t protect others (or whatever shit he should protect).
My employers did not ever arrange any sort of training for me. They accepted me as a trained person and employ me accordingly. (Not everyone can do every job in the security business)
I often see securtiy guards who are weak, fat, untrained. They are ridiculous.
I also see such people in the police. What a disgrace.
The security camera would make an intervention even easier because you have hard evidence. Xou�´d have to restrain yourself from using excessive force in that case.
You say you can�´t control a physical engagement with a teenage girl. Why are you a bouncer in one of the toughest clubs in Philly?
They claimed they were outnumbered, what a ridiculous argument.
Outnumbered by a couple of girls.
I try almost every weekend to get outnumbered by at least 2 girls, but they don�´t make it that easy.
I don�´t know much of your laws. I can tell you that you are supposed to help in such situations in Germany.
If you are in danger of getting injured you don�´t have to intervene physically.
That means your grandma wouldn�´t have to step in, she�´d have to call the police.
Then you still have to consider that unless they put themselves in unreasonable danger security guards in Germany are obligated to protect the stuff and people in their working place.
Failure to do so leads to the possibility of legal consequences.
If you work in a mall and let some kid steal a couple of video games without interfering (as long as it s not dangerous) and you can be convicted for negligent theft.
Watch a bitch beat up a girl and you can be convicted for negligent physical assault. A normal bystander would be in for not helping without that assault thing. You see as a security guard you�´d get punished a lot more than a person who is not involved.
A contract forcing security not to intervene in such a situation would be irrelevant.
I somehow like that a lot more than what you are describing.
[/quote]
Dude, if you’d stop thumping your chest just long enough to read and think, you might have a shot at adding something intelligent to this thread. You’ve already admitted that you were hired as a “security guard” UNTRAINED. And it’s clear that you have no carefully considered the issues before you respond.
First, it is clear from the report that the girl was part of a LARGER GROUP. Whether they were out of camera shot or not, is anyone’s guess but that was my point. She wasn’t alone.
Next, the person that took her purse, unless I’m mistaken, we MALE.
Any employee, guard or not, is retained to perform what they were CONTRACTED to do. It seems you’re not familiar with an observe and report posting. Perhaps you have not considered that the company also has concerns not only for respecting its contract with its vendor, but also for allowing a potentiall untrained employee to become involved in a physical altercation and suffer injury. There are a myriad of issues you that you have not PROFESSIONALLY considered.
Any neanderthal can thump his chest and say, ungawa…me tarzan, me can break up little girlie fight quite easily. But do it without getting attacked in return, escalating the situation and/or getting your employer and its vendor sued.
I referenced pepper spray as a non-lethal tool to disperse CROWDS or GROUPS of people. It’s effective. My point was, they probably were not even armed with at least that much. They got a cell phone and a vest. They are, without dispute, ILL EQUIPPED to become involved in ANY confrontation. I don’t know how they do it in GERMANY, but here, the girls fight back. And before you call us a sissy and say we should be able to beat a girl, that’s not the job!
You say you don’t know our laws. That’s the most intelligent thing you have yet uttered.
And no, you CANNOT easily control a female intended on combat. It’s far easier to control a male. I see you have NO EXPERIENCE in this regard or, maybe they just behave different in GERMANY. In the last 3 months, out of many “incidents”, I cannot recall one male patron attempting to assault a bouncer. In the same time span, I can think of 3 girls who have.
Employer aside, do you want to be in a criminal court room explaining to a judge that you didn’t assault this woman? I don’t. But the larger point is, I’m CHARGED with the DUTY to protect patrons and use REASONABLE FORCE to remove those that are a threat to persons and property. The security guards in question were specifically FORBIDDEN from doing so.
Finally, sounds like you have some interesting laws in Germany. You’d do better to speak on that, because the legal, professional and practical issues here are over your head - or you are just typing before thinking.