[quote]duffyj2 wrote:
Not really, because if it did mess something up, you could always just rewind time and do something else. Problem solved.
Then you’ve screwed something else up. Before long, you’re doing nothing more than spending your entire day rewinding and resetting just to find the most favorable outcome. Rinse and repeat for the rest of eternity every time you wanted to use your power.
What makes you think that everything you do is gonna screw something up? Are you incapable of making good decisions that could result in good consequences?
Unless your life truly sucks, and you truly believe that every single decision you’ve ever made has been a bad one that resulted in bad things happening, AND you are incapable of even conceiving other possible courses of action that may have resulted in better results.
Or, you are an incredibly pessimistic person who truly believes that life is destined to be fucked up, twisted and evil; then, again, I disagree.
Please. It’s not as simple as good decision - good consequence, bad decision bad consequence. The point is that you will be spending your life trying to make everything “optimal”. “Why did this realtionship break down?”; head back and try it again.
“Could I have done better in that interview?”; head back and try it again. “Wrong chat-up line?”; head back and do it again. “Could I have eaten better for the last 6 months?”; head back and try it again.
Eventually your life would cease to have all meaning, you would descend into moral bankrupcy and loose all feeling for anyone and anything aside from yourself. You would be the only “real” one in an unreal world. Everyone else would simply become pawns for you to manipulate in and use to your advantage.
Melancholy would set in first, a sense of meaninglessness. Then desperation. Then insanity.
This is a great idea for a short story.[/quote]
Or, you could wind up living in a sort of utopia, it all depends on how you look at things. If you could indeed find the best possible path for every situation, you could potentially create the best possible world.
You could learn any skill, or talent that you ever wanted to learn, you could absorb all the knowledge that you ever wanted to know, you could do or say anything that you ever wanted to do or say.
I agree that a lot of time would be spent trying out lots of different approaches until you found the one you liked the best, but I don’t really think that you (or at least I) would wind up only seeing people as pawns.
And even if they would, you could say basically the same thing about a lot of super powers. Immortality, invulnerability, invisibility, telekenesis, psychic powers, most of the good ones.
At some point you would be like a god, and could potentially lose sight or your morality, thus causing you to view all other people simply as pawns.
The only thing that would possibly stop you from turning into a tyrant would be your morality. If you were not a moral person to begin with, you would likely wind up seeing people as pawns. If you were though, the super power would not corrupt you (at least not permanently IMO).