[quote]Cockney Blue wrote:
[quote]Brother Chris wrote:
[quote]Cockney Blue wrote:
Help me out on something. Is there somewhere else that you can go other than Heaven or Hell?
Something else I would like your views on, I think we would both agree that someone like Koresh is sick, he has a chemical imbalance in his brain leading him to have delusions that he is hearing God speak to him and also leading him to want sex with lots of underage girls. Now given that he is sick and given that his sickness is driving him to depravity he doesn’t have free will in his choice to sin. Therefore is he actually sinning?[/quote]
Yes, Purgatory and some believe Limbo. However, at some point, if you go Purgatory, you end up in Heaven after being cleansed. Limbo is a little tricky and I’m not exactly sure what it is besides when it comes to the Jews. However it is a subject of interest.
Yes, we agree. I’m not exactly sure what is wrong with Koresh (or much of his actions), but yes it wouldn’t be too far to say he was a sick man.
Well this would matter, let’s say he was possessed by demons, and it wasn’t a chemical imbalance, then yes he would be guilty, because just like vampires (even though vampires are not real) demons cannot enter without your permission. However, if it was in fact a genuine chemical imbalance, and he did in fact have no free will. Then logically he would have sinned, still, but only venial sin, not mortal.[/quote]
Thanks for the reply, I wasn’t sure what the latest Catholic view on Limbo was (I thought they changed their mind recently)
Interesting on the second part, do you literally believe in Demons that possess people then? How would you tell it was a Demon and not a mental illness?[/quote]
I’m not an exorcist, so I am not totally sure. I know on the exorcist teams they have psychologists to make sure that it is not mental illness though. Even though The Exorcist opened the eyes to people about exorcism (the movie was copied after a young boy in a prominent families exorcism) it didn’t give the whole story. There is more to it than walking into a room and tying someone down and throwing holy water on them and saying some Latin prayers.
Yeah, I’m not sure either, that’s why I want to do some research.