Were Women Ever Oppressed in the US?

I’m splitting my reply up over the next three posts. Anyone who knows much about me by now knows why.

Finally getting to this. I’ll try and keep this short, but you know how that goes. Also, despite my years of entrenchment into this country, I in no way consider myself any kind of “expert” on Japanese culture. I have, however, had deeply personal talks with a number of Japanese, both male and female, of many different ages, income and societal levels, and personalities, and by and large it seems my conclusions are fully supported as true by those I’ve talked with. I’d challenge anyone who disagrees with this to ask a Japanese national if any part of my description below is untrue. I am confident they will agree. I’ve already asked them myself.

First: Japanese society suffers from more than just gender inequality. In fact, inequality is actually built into Japanese culture and the collective psyche as a given. It is probably THE sacred cow of Japanese culture. The respect of and concern with social stratification occupies a larger place in the life of the typical Japanese than even religion. I know that sounds like a strong statement, but watch:

Socialization and stratification here begins right away. In the elementary schools, kids are separated boy/girl/boy/girl. During the school year, children take all their classes with the same kids; so one group of sixth graders will not take any classes with any other sixth graders other than those that have been assigned to their “kumi” that year.

It grows FAR more intense starting in jr. high. The “club” system is a supremely powerful, insidious, absolutely ruthless and unforgiving tool to force socialization into the Japanese social structure. The “senpai” (upper-classmen) are to be revered as little gods by their “kohai” (lower-classmen). Neither the senpai’s, not the coach’s, nor the teacher’s word is to be questioned. Ever.

Almost every Saturday, Sunday, and certainly every holiday is filled with mandatory attendance club practice or competitions. Though it is not mentioned and no one appears to notice it, time with one’s family at that time is forcibly supplanted in favor of time with the club. If one ever decides to forgo club attendance, regardless of any ability or past loyalty of that student to the club, she will be subtly punished for her “selfishness.” Quick example of this, I take my students to the US for homestays and school attendance. A worthy endeavor if ever there be one, and certainly a good excuse for one to miss a few days of practice or a comp, no? Well, tell that to one of my 8th grade students, who returned to find her placement in her tennis club had been rearranged after her short absence so that she was given a new doubles partner who happened to be one of the worst players on the team. She wasn’t there and they needed someone to good enough to replace her, and it’s only fair, right? Remember to view this injustice in light of the importance and massive, nearly all-encompassing role the club plays in the life of a typical jr. high school student here.

Can you sense a little bitterness on my part, maybe?

If a student manages to carefully enough ask a superior WHY it is they engage in any of the apparently absurd behaviors or activities they do, the answer is a quick, sharp, circular, “It’s always been done this way!” (Ignoring that this answers the question “how long?” far more appropriately than it does “why?”)

At the risk of carrying this into TLDR I owe you beer for saying banana in your next post territory, quickly (haha):

Discrimination against women is only one part of the bigger picture here:

Men over 65 (sometimes as low as 60 now) are forced to quit jobs they both enjoy and are productive at. Many times a company will actually cut off its nose to spite its face in this regard, as Japanese men typically have forged their entire identity around their job position. Many of them, in perfect socialized style, have actually given up any true relationship with their families in respect to their company. Working well in excess of 8 hours every salaried work day is a given here. In some companies, being the last one in the office becomes almost an unconscious competition with one’s coworkers. I have personally worked in companies and witnessed first-hand the live-to-work culture (as opposed to the American work-to-live mentality) in which the first half of the day is one protracted gathering at the figurative water cooler, seeing near to zero productivity, followed by a fierce, laser-focused shift into massive productivity after 5pm (when they should just be going home) that sees much of the prior 8 hours’ work get tackled over the next 4 hours or so. They are not being “lazy” in the first instance. They would literally run out of work by late afternoon if they were moderately productive throughout the day. Japanese are anything but lazy.

Again, this is programmed into the system. They are helpless to do anything about it even, for the most part. In the above example, the workers would receive a call from the head office in Hiroshima around 10pm every night for a report on what they’d done that day. They, including the peon who had to open the store at 8:30am, ALL have to stay until they get that phone call and let the district manager know that they’ve been “productive” and how so.

I haven’t even gotten into concepts of “in-group” and “out-group,” or “tate-mae” and “honne” (roughly: “social facade” and “true feelings,” respectively), discrimination against other Asians, the weird role Westerners hold (also separated into race) in this society, the way pets are treated and animals are viewed (you don’t want to hear some of these things nor do I want to say them) or about a billion other things. Again, GENERALLY SPEAKING.

My point: Japan is a REALLY interesting case with regard to “roles.” I think it’s evident by my tone in telling some of this that I do not hold a lot of these “roles,” in the highest regard.

I do want to make clear, however, that I could write up a similar, almost mirror opposite diatribe against America, and it would sound just as bad. Seriously. I hire both Japanese and westerners, for instance, and let me tell you, I sincerely wish I DID NOT have to hire any western employees. I mean that. They are typically selfish, unloyal, sometimes lazy, argumentative, demanding, and most are not able to follow simple, clear instructions without thinking that somehow doing it “their” way is better (forgetting that my decisions are based upon 9 years of experience including actually owning the business as opposed to their year or two and I’m paying them $3000 a month out of my own pocket to have it done MY way!).

I stand firm to my prior statement about the roles of men and women in any culture. My statement has nothing to do with oppression or de facto mandatory social obligations, but with what each person is suited to do. I’ll stop here, believe it or not. I certainly hope someone read this far because this was probably the most time, energy and emotion I’ve ever put into any forum post, at least that I can remember.

[quote]TheBodyGuard wrote:

[quote]Brother Chris wrote:

Really? You going to hire a housekeeper or babysitter that is homeless? Barmaid? Waitress?

I like my possessions to stay in my house personally. [/quote]

Happens ALL THE TIME. In fact, it’s far more difficult for a woman to be truly “homeless” than for a man inasmuch as there are more shelter resources that cater to women and women with children as opposed to homeless men. [/quote]

Exactly, because they have a harder time providing for themselves. :wink:

The only concrete role I see between man and woman is that both need to participate in their hood, such as fatherhood and motherhood, whether that be spiritually and biologically or just spiritually. Fatherhood and motherhood are of course distinct but at the same time similar, but more so, and actually, complimentary to one another. A woman in the workforce will not make her hard, not fulfilling her role in her motherhood will. This applies for men and their fatherhood.

Great posts Cortes, I’m busy, but I want to try to continue this conversation

Since I am sick today and trying to generate the perfect Pandora channel I think all future responses to all threads should be in the form of song.

Ugh, Ani DiFranco is the absolute epitome of the modern, insecure, hyper-masculine female who has confused femininity with weakness and, so desperate to exalt the preeminence of the female, has unwittingly paid the male sex the weird honor of attempting to apotheosize it through imitation.

If I have to listen to a liberal, feminist, solo artist with a healthy distrust of men, give me Tori Amos any day of the week. She’s more original, more talented, and actually invokes a stirring of the loins.

[quote]Gambit_Lost wrote:
Great posts Cortes, I’m busy, but I want to try to continue this conversation[/quote]

Thanks, Gambit, looking forward to it.

I like Ani. I wasn’t fond of her softer experimental time but she’s gotten her swagger back. I don’t think she is hypermasculine by any means, but certainly she’s not for everyone. I remember seeing her about 20 years ago in concert and it coming up that she’s seen as a very user unfriendly folk singer since she doesn’t do requests so it had been brought up to her she should seed the crowd with some people with her set list and change her image and how she found it hilarious. Stuff like 32 flavors is softer but I like her uncompromising and hard.

You know you can’t be soft when you are

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NTyAZTvLfAM

[quote]Cortes wrote:
Ugh, Ani DiFranco is the absolute epitome of the modern, insecure, hyper-masculine female who has confused femininity with weakness and, so desperate to exalt the preeminence of the female, has unwittingly paid the male sex the weird honor of attempting to apotheosize it through imitation.

If I have to listen to a liberal, feminist, solo artist with a healthy distrust of men, give me Tori Amos any day of the week. She’s more original, more talented, and actually invokes a stirring of the loins. [/quote]

I don’t know this Ani girl, but Tori Amos has destroyed her face with too much plastic surgery. You wouldn’t recognize her. So sad really.

[quote]ephrem wrote:

[quote]Cortes wrote:
Ugh, Ani DiFranco is the absolute epitome of the modern, insecure, hyper-masculine female who has confused femininity with weakness and, so desperate to exalt the preeminence of the female, has unwittingly paid the male sex the weird honor of attempting to apotheosize it through imitation.

If I have to listen to a liberal, feminist, solo artist with a healthy distrust of men, give me Tori Amos any day of the week. She’s more original, more talented, and actually invokes a stirring of the loins. [/quote]

I don’t know this Ani girl, but Tori Amos has destroyed her face with too much plastic surgery. You wouldn’t recognize her. So sad really.[/quote]

Yah it really ruins her as a singer…oh wait.

[quote]groo wrote:

[quote]ephrem wrote:

[quote]Cortes wrote:
Ugh, Ani DiFranco is the absolute epitome of the modern, insecure, hyper-masculine female who has confused femininity with weakness and, so desperate to exalt the preeminence of the female, has unwittingly paid the male sex the weird honor of attempting to apotheosize it through imitation.

If I have to listen to a liberal, feminist, solo artist with a healthy distrust of men, give me Tori Amos any day of the week. She’s more original, more talented, and actually invokes a stirring of the loins. [/quote]

I don’t know this Ani girl, but Tori Amos has destroyed her face with too much plastic surgery. You wouldn’t recognize her. So sad really.[/quote]

Yah it really ruins her as a singer…oh wait.
[/quote]

Yeah, for me it does. Same with Joe Jackson. He did the same thing and looks awful nowadays. I can’t look at the guy without cringing and that affects how I enjoy his music.

I don’t mean to say that earlier work is less enjoyable, but I wouldn’t want to see him perform.

Just my opinion though.

[quote]ephrem wrote:

[quote]groo wrote:

[quote]ephrem wrote:

[quote]Cortes wrote:
Ugh, Ani DiFranco is the absolute epitome of the modern, insecure, hyper-masculine female who has confused femininity with weakness and, so desperate to exalt the preeminence of the female, has unwittingly paid the male sex the weird honor of attempting to apotheosize it through imitation.

If I have to listen to a liberal, feminist, solo artist with a healthy distrust of men, give me Tori Amos any day of the week. She’s more original, more talented, and actually invokes a stirring of the loins. [/quote]

I don’t know this Ani girl, but Tori Amos has destroyed her face with too much plastic surgery. You wouldn’t recognize her. So sad really.[/quote]

Yah it really ruins her as a singer…oh wait.
[/quote]

Yeah, for me it does. Same with Joe Jackson. He did the same thing and looks awful nowadays. I can’t look at the guy without cringing and that affects how I enjoy his music.

I don’t mean to say that earlier work is less enjoyable, but I wouldn’t want to see him perform.

Just my opinion though.
[/quote]
I have seen them both perform multiple times, since I mostly like female singers which I am sure has some clear psychopathology, but Ani puts on a concert with energy and power and its like a mini version of a big stadium show with people…mostly lesbians :P…dancing standing singing along etc. One time when I saw tori I remember this drunk dude became a little overcome by his own feelings and keep yelling things like I"d fuck her. People tracked down and usher and had him removed…while I admit his yelling was annoying the fact you could hear him and that yelling at a concert wasn’t appreciated shows the different kind of shows they put on. Ani is good looking though she butched it up for a while I think to help her image wise but after she had her baby she seems to mostly let her hair be long and crazy.

I think it doesn’t say a lot about oppression but I do think female singers that sing sexy songs are expected to deliver visually. Listen to this which I think is one of the hotter sex songs I’ve heard. Then look up what she looks like afterward and tell me if it ruins it for you. Vid NSFW some boobies!

[quote]groo wrote:

[quote]ephrem wrote:

Yeah, for me it does. Same with Joe Jackson. He did the same thing and looks awful nowadays. I can’t look at the guy without cringing and that affects how I enjoy his music.

I don’t mean to say that earlier work is less enjoyable, but I wouldn’t want to see him perform.

Just my opinion though.
[/quote]
I have seen them both perform multiple times, since I mostly like female singers which I am sure has some clear psychopathology, but Ani puts on a concert with energy and power and its like a mini version of a big stadium show with people…mostly lesbians :P…dancing standing singing along etc. One time when I saw tori I remember this drunk dude became a little overcome by his own feelings and keep yelling things like I"d fuck her. People tracked down and usher and had him removed…while I admit his yelling was annoying the fact you could hear him and that yelling at a concert wasn’t appreciated shows the different kind of shows they put on. Ani is good looking though she butched it up for a while I think to help her image wise but after she had her baby she seems to mostly let her hair be long and crazy.

I think it doesn’t say a lot about oppression but I do think female singers that sing sexy songs are expected to deliver visually. Listen to this which I think is one of the hotter sex songs I’ve heard. Then look up what she looks like afterward and tell me if it ruins it for you. Vid NSFW some boobies![/quote]

She’s not very attractive, but neither am I. I’m not judging a person on her/his looks but on the fact that they’ve destroyed their natural looks.

I commend her, and I never heard of Melissa Ferrick, for staying who she is inspite of media and business pressures for artists to be attractive.

Can’t say I like the song very much, but that’s neither here nor there, lol.