[quote]Sweet Revenge wrote:
[quote]Brother Chris wrote:
[quote]Sweet Revenge wrote:
I’m trying to understand your earlier statement… ‘a woman cannot be in persona Christi, it would be impossible even if we did try and ordain a woman. It would just be invalid.’
It doesn’t make any sense to me, especially in light of Galatians 3:28, noted above.
[/quote]
Galatians 3:28 has nothing to do with the priesthood (not anything explicit anyway). You want to know why a woman cannot be a priest? There is different layers to this question, kind of complicated. I’ll go threw them briefly and if you have questions on them, I’ll try and answer them and if I can’t, I will find an answer for you somewhere. Note, I don’t know much about this subject so I had to do some research (reason for taking so long to respond).
Why did G-d make it so that only men can be ordained priests? I don’t know. That is his plan and when I get to Heaven I’ll be sure to ask him about that.
Even though I don’t understand G-d’s reasonings I do believe it to be the unchangeable truth that only men can be ordained priests (this is different than preachers and theologians, &c. a lot of women make good preachers because they are very sympathetic, which some men tend to lack. I have met a few Sheed women and they are quite fine preachers, however they would never attempt to preach women ordination. As well, there is a few women theologians that I cherish like the wonderful lady Dr. Alice von Hildebrand who I have met on a few cases and I would recommend her and her husband who is a pure genius).
Theologically speaking…women can’t become priests because the priest, as I said, is ‘in persona Christi’ and Christ is 1) a man, 2) married to his Bride, the Church. Christ is referred to as our Bridegroom and the Church is his Bride, which with the two become one flesh turns into the Church being the body of Christ. A priest is married to the Bride, our Mother, the Church. And, it is a lie that a bride can marry a bride, so because of G-d’s plan (only he knows his reasons) a woman couldn’t possibly be ordained.
So, these congregations where they have women preachers…awesome. I have two women who preach on Saturday and Wednesday down town, but they both know they can’t become priests (and both happenstance to wear veils when praying).
Now, on the abilities of women to be priests. Yes, women would make good priests, they have the characteristics: they are caring, sympathetic, understanding, they listen, they are usually good with administrative work, good with little kids. However, the priesthood has is special because it is brought into the oneness of Fatherhood. Priests are called Father for a reason, because from Peter and Paul they were call Fathers, and Abraham was known as Father Abraham. Jesus’ priesthood is in form of the Leviticus priesthood, they offer up sacrifices to the Lord, and they have to be men. However, the only Sacrifice that is sufficient to the Father, is the Son.
Tradition…from the early writings like the Didache we can see that only men were allowed to be Priests.
Inference…we can infer from the Bible that if Jesus wanted women to be priests he had one greatest human alive to make a priest (two if you count Mary Magdalen), his beloved Mother. She always (and I mean always) followed the Lord’s will and never sinned (I mean never), she would have been great as a priest, she’s our Mother! I mean the Jesus did pick her after all, you’d think that if women could be priests, he would have made her one. But, he didn’t.[/quote]
OK, so it has to do more with fitting into the traditional and allegorical story of the bridegroom and bride than ‘in persona Christi’. Since in Christ, there is no male or female.
[/quote]
No. It has a lot to do with in person Christi, there is a difference between in persona Christi and in the body of Christ. When a priest is in persona Christi, he acts as Christ himself, as the high priest as the one priest. When we are in the body of Christ, we do not act as Christ himself at least not in the position of high priest.
And the no male or female is referring to the Jewish tradition that people with money were looked upon with favor by G-d and that women were second rate. It doesn’t mean that women can be priests, just like man can’t be a mother.