[quote]Kainjer wrote:
steveo5801 wrote:
Kainjer wrote:
steveo5801 wrote:
Kainjer wrote:
Kainjer wrote:
steveo5801 wrote:
No one is saying that the behaviors you describe as “sins” are admirable or beneficial, these behaviors are reprehensible. They are simply saying that outside of the context in which you have defined the term, it does not have the same significance.
I think you miss my point. I do address this to unbelievers of every kind. Those who don’t believe in God or Jesus, or those who believe that there is a God, but reject God’s plan of salvation.
People who don’t believe still sin.
What I am asking is that since we all sin, and there will be eternal consequences for that sin when we face the Ultimate Judge of the Universe, what is YOUR plan to escape punishment if it is not God’s plan?
And you are missing my point. The question you are ultimately proposing still defines “sin” as a christian principle.
OK – do you think that lying, stealing, having sex with another man’s wife, are good things? What do you call these things then?
Certainly not. That has been addressed in my original post (see above), as well as in a follow-up post (see below). Non-believers aren’t saying that these behaviors are good, they just don’t attach any theological qualifiers to them. If “sin” is a crime against God, and one does not believe in God, it is not a “sin”. It is still a bad behavior, and is still not beneficial to society, but there are no eternal consequences attached.[/quote]
OK – you want to call these types of behaviors “bad,” instead of sin – I have no problem with that. But let me ask you something on this point.
How do you know that lying, murder, stealing, having sex with someone’s wife, are bad behaviors? Where do you get that from? Isn’t true that we have a conscience [con = with; science = knowledge]? Our consciences tell us that these things are “bad.” Well where did the conscience come from? Who gave us this knowledge of good and evil? (Remember what Satan said to Adam and Eve in the garden that we would have the knowledge of good and evil?).
Again, my question is who gave us this ability to know right from wrong without ever being told? I am interested on your thoughts about this. [quote]
You are also including the christian idea of “eternal consequences” as reward/punishment for one’s actions in life. People who do not believe in God do not have anyone/thing to be “sinning” against, hence no “sin”. Bad deeds? Yes. Poor choices? Sure. “Sin”, as you define it? No. Nor do people who don’t believe in God worry about or even consider the possibilty of “eternal consequences”.[/quote]
I know. I used to be in that category as well. Kind of like a man on a fast moving boat down a long winding river. It is great fun and sport for much time, until it goes over the cliff that you were not aware nor didn’t believe was coming. That is unfortunate, but the cliff is closer than you think. [quote]
Well, I would say that few criminals ever expect to get caught, and certainly don’t think about the serious consequences for their crimes at the time they are commiting those crimes. This “non-belief” in the consequences still doesn’t make the reality of consequences go away.
Same in the eternal realm.
I have worked in the court system for almost 10 years, first in corrections, and currently in probation. One thing I can say is that career criminals DO expect to get caught. They see it as a job hazard. They just don’t expect to get caught every time. Most tell me that they are getting away with about 20-30 crimes for every one that they get caught for, which they consider to be an acceptable risk.
Why must everything have a purpose? Why is it a common trait of human nature to be unable to accept that we may simply just “be”, without ultimate cause, ultimate design or ultimate purpose? Do we as humans really need to feel that important, when “ultimately” we are not?
Because everything does have a purpose. That’s why. If the little things on Earth have a purpose, how much more the ultimate Creator of the Universe has a purpose?
When I was a kid, my father would tell me that “because” is not an answer. Now I understand why he would never let me get away with trying to use it as one.
Take care~
and you do the same[/quote]