The Story No American Publisher Wanted

Former Marine Staff Sergeant Jimmy Massey has published a book in France called, “Kill Kill Kill.” It accuses U.S. soldiers of atrocities in Iraq, including the killing of civilian men, women, and children.
Our next guest says Massey is lying and he can prove it. Joining us now is “St. Louis Post” dispatch writer Ron Harris. He was embedded with Jimmy Massey’s unit in Iraq. Welcome, Ron.

RON HARRIS, “ST. LOUIS POST”: Thank you. COSTELLO: You know, if this guy is lying, that’s just vile. Because he’s saying some vile things about our men and women over in Iraq.

HARRIS: Yes, that’s very true. I mean, he is claiming that marines intentionally killed civilians, that he intentionally killed civilians. And at times, he claims that they intentionally killed civilians based on orders from the superiors. And the fact is, it just isn’t true.

[CAROL] COSTELLO: OK, let’s get to specifics now. He claimed, as you said, that Marines fired on and killed peaceful Iraqi protesters and were sometimes ordered by higher-ups to do that. How can you disprove that?

HARRIS: Well, two or three things. Number one, I was there in Iraq when – I was in Baghdad when we initially pulled in. I was with Massey’s unit. I was embedded with the unit, as were three other – four other journalists, actually. And we went to that prison and I was there the next morning.

And not only did I not see any protesters, nobody saw any protesters. And not for weeks. Because during that time, it was a very, very dangerous period. It was basically four kinds of Iraqis. There were Iraqis who were happy to see the marines. There were Iraqis who were shooting at the marines and me, too, and the other journalists. There were Iraqis who were looting and that was probably what we saw most of. And there were finally Iraqis staying at home because they were afraid.

COSTELLO: Yes, but Ron, if there was completely untrue, I mean, this guy has made it into pretty big publications like “Vanity Fair.” He’s written a book that’s bee published in France.

HARRIS: Oh, it’s been published everywhere. Nobody – in not one publication or not one broadcast, is there any corroboration. It’s just Jimmy Massey’s story. Nobody ever called a journalists who were covering him. Nobody ever interviewed the marines, which I did all of. Nobody ever checked his story. They don’t even have another source that says on background or another source who didn’t want to be quoted. It’s just Jimmy Massey’s story.

COSTELLO: Well, let’s face it – let’s say these stories were true. Would the marines – wouldn’t be forthcoming about that. Oh, yes, we killed innocent Iraqi people. They’re not going to admit that.

HARRIS: No, no, no. That’s not true. In fact, the marines, we were there embedded with the marines. And the marines did shoot innocent civilians. And we covered that. In fact, covered that – the photographer with me, Andrew Cartero (ph) shot pictures of innocent civilians who had been accidentally shot by the Marine Corps. We wrote stories and Andy took photographs of a British television crew that was shot and killed by the Marine Corps on the second day of the war. COSTELLO: Well, Ron, let’s go to some of those photos. We have one photo that this photographer took, and it shows two women who are bloody. You say this further disproves Jimmy Massey’s story. In what way?

HARRIS: In that case, Jimmy Massey claimed that a 4-year-old girl was shot in the head. That was the particular shooting incident. In fact, there were civilian shot in that car by Marines. Nobody died.

Andrew Cartero, again, the photographer for “The Post Dispatch,” took those photographs. And as you can see in those pictures, there are people there. Nobody died. I talked to the medic who treated them. And I traveled with him for more than a month, Petty Officer Justin Poviance (ph). He told me nobody died in that incident.

COSTELLO: Well, let’s go to one other picture, and this is really gruesome. So I’ going to warn people to turn away if you want to see it. But this a tractor trailer. Jimmy Massey says it was filled with women, children and men. What do you say?

HARRIS: We were there. Those are photographs by Andrew Katraro. I saw it. Michael Phillips from “Wall Street Journal” saw it. Robbie Nesbit (ph) from Associated Press saw it. Those were men on a military base who had been killed by U.S. artillery, but there were no women or children in those tractor trailers. Those tractor trailer were used as sort of a makeshift morgue. They were refrigerated trucks, and they had been killed by American bombing. Initially the military thought that they had been killed by Saddam Hussein. They thought maybe it was a war crime.

COSTELLO: OK, I have to ask you this before I have to let you go.

HARRIS: OK.

COSTELLO: Why would this staff sergeant, Jimmy Massey, lie about these things, and say such terrible things about his own comrades?

HARRIS: Well, one of the things that has happened – number one, Jimmy Massey, I don’t know why, but I can just speculate a couple of things. Number one, Jimmy Massey was honorably discharged for post- traumatic stress syndrome. The second thing, Jimmy Massey has profited off of this. He does have a book. He has a Web site in which he sells his story on a CD for a hundred dollars. I think it’s called jimmymassey.com. So it’s been profitable for Jimmy Massey to keep telling this lie.

COSTELLO: Ron Harris from the “St. Louis Post Dispatch,” thank you for joining us this morning.

Maybe it wasn’t published because it is bullshit.

Anyone who has ever served in the military, particularly in combat, could see thru it.

Nobody becomes a “killing machine”. When someone cracks they get rotated out quickly. Combat is for those with a clear head. It’s all business. Marines are highly disciplined troops, not third world fucknuts. Marines call each other Marines. That’s you first bullshit clue. Not soldiers or anything else. I never heard anyone refer to their rifle as an “M-16”. It’s your rifle or your weapon. Somebody pretending to describe combat or a civilian would call it an M-16.

I know you desperately want to believe that American soldiers kill innocent civilians and are murderers but they do not.

I never met a psychotic killer in the Army. I saw a lot of guys who were very good at taking the lives of the enemy but nobody took pleasure in it. Warriors don’t enjoy killing the enemy.
People who pretend to be warriors just think they should.

Did these things happen. Doubtful. If it did you wouldn’t be reading about it in a book. CNN would have picked it up.

I’m just guessin’, but I’ll bet that fahd (or his family or goat molesting rag heads) is originally from a Middle Eastern “country”.

He probably is. Which means he’s probably biased.

As are you all (especially the more “patriotic” on here).

Or are you too blind to see your own nationalistic fervor?

Yeah, my friend was over there (Army) and he never told me about killing innocents and shit! He actually showed me videotape of him talking with children and other civilians. I went through the whole recruiting process, no way would a “retarded” person get in the marines. I was in the Army and we had some dumb ones but not retarded. After reading that story; I call bullshit!..smell it!?

[quote]thebigdogbarks wrote:
I’m just guessin’, but I’ll bet that fahd (or his family or goat molesting rag heads) is originally from a Middle Eastern “country”. [/quote]

Wrong guess! I live in Wales and I am oriental.

Nice try though. It really shows your intelligence and maturity to resort to associating particullar people with certain racist ideas.

Neocon thrives on people like you,

Fahd

[quote]thebigdogbarks wrote:
I’m just guessin’, but I’ll bet that fahd (or his family or goat molesting rag heads) is originally from a Middle Eastern “country”. [/quote]

I’m just guessin’, but I’ll bet that thebigdogbarks (or his family or donut eating fat fucks) is originally from a “country” called Amerikkka

[quote]sjoconn wrote:

Also, the Army has certain standards for recruits, and Im sure the Marines do as well. His “Of Mice and Men” charactor wouldnt have made the cut. In fact, he would have been in trouble for getting someone like this to the MEPS.
[/quote]

This parts not really accurate I recall a special student from my high school joining the Marines. I saw him 4 yrs after and he was definetly not the same kid.

[quote]Snoop wrote:
sjoconn wrote:

Also, the Army has certain standards for recruits, and Im sure the Marines do as well. His “Of Mice and Men” charactor wouldnt have made the cut. In fact, he would have been in trouble for getting someone like this to the MEPS.

This parts not really accurate I recall a special student from my high school joining the Marines. I saw him 4 yrs after and he was definetly not the same kid.[/quote]

But I doudt he was the “retard” as described by the so-called hero of this story.
Definitly not the same kid? Just out curiosity would you say better, worse, or just different?

[quote]fahd wrote:
Nice try though. It really shows your intelligence and maturity to resort to associating particullar people with certain racist ideas.

Neocon thrives on people like you,

I’m just guessin’, but I’ll bet that thebigdogbarks (or his family or donut eating fat fucks) is originally from a “country” called Amerikkka [/quote]

So to summerize this thread: you post s BS story which people then say is BS. So then you come back with something that reads something like “you guys are neocon stupid heads and I hate America”. Now thats good discussion there. Wow.

I have to call BS on this as well. Others have stated the obvious reaosns for this.
I would also like to add that many innocent people do die in a war. BUT I saw more innocent people dead in Iraq because if the terrorists than because if US forces. And guess who was there trying to help the civilains and the wounded terrorists? The very same hated US military. Its ironic when a terrorists tries to kill you, fails, gets wounded himself, and then cries out for the US medics to save him. You think they would help an American that just tried to kill them? Nope, they cut their head off with a dull knife. This is what these people are all about. They are about as worthy of life as the shit on the bottom of my boot. And the damn media plays right into their hands. Its all BS if you ask me.

[quote]sjoconn wrote:
So to summerize this thread: you post s BS story which people then say is BS. So then you come back with something that reads something like “you guys are neocon stupid heads and I hate America”. Now thats good discussion there. Wow.

[/quote]

Try understand it in the context the that Thebigdogbarks racist remarks.

Thebigdogbarks first started insulting all Arabs (not that I am one) by calling them “goat molesters and ragheads”.

The article is not and cannot be 100% true, it is, however, a general and true reflection of what many people in western Europe think about the war and people like thebigdogbarks only reinforcing the R*dneck (rainjack made it a dirty word)Stereotype.

I apologise for the unnecessary donut-eating remark; I personally have NOTHING against American people, I did it on purpose to demonstrate some people’s hypocracy: they act as if you can call an entire gourp of human being ragheads and goldmolesters just for being born in the middle east, while its not ok to joke about Americans.

You’re always right and I’m always wrong,

Fahd

[quote]GeneralLee wrote:
I have to call BS on this as well. Others have stated the obvious reaosns for this.
I would also like to add that many innocent people do die in a war. BUT I saw more innocent people dead in Iraq because if the terrorists than because if US forces. And guess who was there trying to help the civilains and the wounded terrorists? The very same hated US military. Its ironic when a terrorists tries to kill you, fails, gets wounded himself, and then cries out for the US medics to save him. You think they would help an American that just tried to kill them? Nope, they cut their head off with a dull knife. This is what these people are all about. They are about as worthy of life as the shit on the bottom of my boot. And the damn media plays right into their hands. Its all BS if you ask me.[/quote]

Don’t confuse acts against civilians (beheading of reportsers etc…) and acts against the US military; the first one is obviously an act of terrorism, while attacking the US military is an act of war (by the people against the occupying force).

Its not either all BS or all true, most controversial stories have some truth in them.

[quote]sjoconn wrote:
Just a few minor problems. Here it states “After 12 years in the Marines” but then in the same paragraph states “The army denies the facts”.

My ex-wife worked at recruiting command and I have several friends who are recruiters. The statement “a recruiter has only one thing in his head if he wants to pay his rent: landing contracts” is misleading at best and a flat-out lie at worst. Recruiters are not paid a commission. There is a lot of politics in recruiting, and there is a quota, but you wont loose any rent money.
Also, the Army has certain standards for recruits, and Im sure the Marines do as well. His “Of Mice and Men” charactor wouldnt have made the cut. In fact, he would have been in trouble for getting someone like this to the MEPS.

I have several years in (more than the “hero” of this story), and have worked with all services and never once have I heard of the rank (formal or informal) of “Chief-Sergeant”.

He states “The M-16’s 5.56 is a nasty bullet: it doesn’t kill all at once. For example, it can enter the chest and come out at the knee, tearing all the internal organs on the way through.” This is common in many rounds including 7.62 x 59 the round commonly used by our enemies.

His little story about shooting up the car when it didnt stop, Im sorry, but thats just good sense when that is a common TTP (tactic, technique, procedure) of the enemy to kill you. I would do it and sleep well that night.

At best this article has many credibility problems.

In regards to posting other stories; we have provided medical and dental care to many people who have never had the opportunity to recieve healthcare. But we never see those stories. I hate to bust bubbles, but we do a lot of good stuff. Actually we’ve helped more people there than we killed. Maybe thats the problem.

As far as blood on everyones hands; I sleep well at night. How about you?
[/quote]

The Marine Corps has no rank of Chief -Sergeant and all the other little incorrect details pretty much prove this to be bullshit.

[quote]wtagye wrote:
The Marine Corps has no rank of Chief -Sergeant and all the other little incorrect details pretty much prove this to be bullshit. [/quote]

I am sure that this guy (who’s been in the marines for many years) would know this obvious flaw if he was making it up.

However, his book was in French and the official English Translation isn’t out yet; while this article is translated from a newspaper article in France. It is definetly a translation error.

Fahd

Original (French)

http://www.nouvelobs.com/articles/p2138/a284490.html

Translation:

http://www.truthout.org/docs_2005/110205A.shtml

[quote]fahd wrote:
wtagye wrote:
The Marine Corps has no rank of Chief -Sergeant and all the other little incorrect details pretty much prove this to be bullshit.

I am sure that this guy (who’s been in the marines for many years) would know this obvious flaw if he was making it up.

However, his book was in French and the official English Translation isn’t out yet; while this article is translated from a newspaper article in France. It is definetly a translation error.

Fahd[/quote]

Seems a little far fetched to me. Why is this book published in french? Does it mean this guy is french and served in the american military?

There is alot of anti-american sentiment floating around these days. Think about it though, where would the world be is there wasn’t anybody to stand up to the type of people that use their religious beliefs to kill and maim innocent people. Being from canada i have nothing but respect for the people that put themselves in harms way just to ensure that i have the freedom of choice.

Plus, if you dont want to get shot in a war, maybe you should stay the fuck home and not ram blockades with your car. I doubt many of the men and women that serve in any form or organzied military are cold blooded killers. Its good to talk the talk when your life isn’t in jeporady from some person that shakes your hand and then shoots you in the back of the head when your not looking.

I see that some of you picked up on how ridiculous this story is. For those of you that didn’t and think Marines are mindless killers, let’s look at his story.

About the protestors, he said his unit was shot at. Obviously they turned on the protestors and opened fire since they are the only ones in the area. The car that got shot up did not stop at an obvious check point. In which case the Marines had every right to open fire on it to stop it(ever hear of “car bomb” and “suicide bomber”)?

And one of the posters were correct about his rank, there are no chief sergeants in the Marines, as I was a Marine and know first hand.

I bet everybody on this forum knows at least one person that was in the Marines or other branch of service, try asking them before you start talking out the side of your mouth. Also another poster was correct about how Marines refer to each other, we never call each other soldiers.

Have we killed innocent civilians? Yes, but this is what happens in any war unfortunately. I bet if we were fighting a conventional army the civilian casualties would be a lot less. Terrorists look just like the civilians, so they can walk right up to you and smile and would never know you were standing in front of one. Perhaps this has a lot of Marines and soldiers on edge. Can you imagine being surrounded by your enemies and yet don’t know who they are until it is too late?

My best friend is still in the Marines and told me one story about how it is over there. Marines train the Iraqi police over there, the problem is some of them were part of Saddams bathe party. At the end of a day of training the Marines are leaving and all of a sudden they get shot at. They go back to the police officers they just trained and ask was it them that shot at them and they deny it. I know the story has more to it, but that’s just the facts.

And some people do end up with mental problems from combat. After all, it’s not natural to kill your own species. Some people can handle it and some can’t that’s all.

If this guy was in the Marines, he’s obviously bitter about his experience in the Corps, but that happens to a lot of people, not eveyone likes military life. I personally love the Corps and don’t regret my time in, granted it was only four years, but if it wasn’t for the Corps I probably would not have job that I have now that allows me to take care of my family the way that I want.

Sorry it’s a little long winded, but I can’t stand people bad mouthing my Corps, especially when they have know idea what they’re talking about.

Adrian Griffin
GET STRONGER!!!

[quote]fahd wrote:
Nice try though. It really shows your intelligence and maturity to resort to associating particullar people with certain racist ideas.
[/quote]

I like the way you call out someone for ‘racist remarks’ if he is on the right, but you defend the same type of name-calling and racist blather when it is directed at southern whites.

Your hypocrisy is smelling up the political forums.

[quote]Gl;itch.e wrote:
Zap Branigan wrote:
No doubt, but the last numbers I have seen (from the UN?) showed the terrorists were responsibly for most of the civilian deaths in Iraq.

american sanctions were responsible for countless deaths after the first gulf war. …[/quote]

I guess the U.S. should not have invaded Kuwait…oh wait we didn’t?

You dont get to break the law AND decide how you get punished.