Black Panther is a character I refrained from using because we have to go a little deeper into what he’s supposed to represent. On the surface, he is BORING but this is what he’s supposed to be. He is essentially a modern day take on a traditional folk hero. Like Jet Li in the Once Upon a Time in China series. He is commanding and somewhat rigid, yet displays his humanity from his insecurity when succeeding the position left by his father, and the way he interacts with his sister like a couple of kids bickering. This let’s people identify with him. He has a deep sense of honor and an unwavering moral compass dictated by tradition, a figure of authority and leadership that people wish for, and are willing to serve in very shitty times(think about the state of the rest of Africa within the context of the story).
Which is why he had to agree to fight the guy with the dreadlocks even though he was already the King. That wasn’t a plot hole. To go against this, and therefore revolt against the archaic rules dictated by tradition, he needed to go through death and rebirth first.
The mistake they made wasn’t making him almost “perfect”, hence boring. This is what this kind of character is supposed to be like, and the actor played him perfectly. They just didn’t have interesting side characters to play off his rigidity. His sister was the only one. They needed entertaining characters on his side to do stuff like challenge his adherence to tradition by getting into trouble which requires him to reluctantly assert his authority. Instead, they had a spear throwing chick with him who was even more rigid. That’s why he only works when he’s with the other Avengers.
You know that the biggest difference between Black Panther and Captain Marvel is despite them both being boring characters.
Black Panther HAS HONOR.
At the start of Captain Marvel, Brie Larson asks Jude Law to practice unarmed combat with her. She already has her “laser blasts from her hands” powers. Jude Law doesn’t. He beats her and mansplains stuff to her. She gets angry and blasts him with her laser hands.
At the end, she is all powerful. Jude Law is alone and more or less beaten since his entire gang has been killed. He asks her to fight him without using her powers as an advantage. This is standard movie shit. Black Panther would have done that even if he was at a disadvantage because of fighting skills, and would have won somehow by using his wits or his opponent’s strength against him or something. She, however, immediately blasts him with an even more powerful laser blast and he flies comically into the distance, turning it all into a joke.
What are you telling me? She’s a sore loser? He’s still talking down to her after all that shit so he deserves it? He’s a fucking villain, for fuck’s sake. That’s what they do. What was he expected to do? Go, “Brie, you’re an empowered, strong, independent woman! Not gonna tell you what to do, but may I suggest that we have a hand to hand fight and perhaps you might want to give me a chance by not using your blaster powers for I am but a weak little man while you reside upon a pedestal high above the petty patriarchal disputes our kind engage in. No pressure. Just a suggestion. Ok? You still call the shots. You’re in control of your life. You are beautiful no matter what they say!”?
I get that there’s probably a juvenile message about “leveling the playing fields” or “not letting men dictate the terms and shit” in there somewhere but this is not how it’s done if you want people to have any respect for the character other than the fact that she’s a systemically oppressed woman who simply must have your unfettered respect and adoration by default or you’re an evil sexist troll who hates ALL women.
Gywenth Paltrow: HOT. Unbelievably HOT. Pillar of strength for Ironman. She is basically everything he isn’t - responsible, accountable, objective, and a LEADER. Tony isn’t one. He’s outright defiant of authority, requiring her to keep him grounded. Her limitation is that all this super power stuff is foreign, and therefore, intimidating to her, which is why she acts like a damsel in distress when shit goes down. If they had any sense, they would come up with a whole new story outside of the comics following through with the plot with her acquiring those powers in Ironman 3, learning to use them, and assuming leadership of the Avengers if Tony Stark dies. Barring that, she’s that bitchy wife your drinking buddy is afraid off which is why he has to leave the bar before 10pm.
Scarlet Witch: Outcast, emotionally vulnerable, reluctant hero without a sense of duty, hangs around and does what she does for kinship, will probably run off to a secluded life in a small province in China with the red colored guy if she had the choice and you’ll see her in a couple of years carrying an infant while ferociously bargaining at the market for the price of a pound of beef while the young kids around there whom she’s friendly with call her “auntie”. The red colored guy won’t be at the bar. He’ll be at home with Ms Olsen with glasses of red wine watching science stuff on National Geographic just to pick apart the mistakes. “That’s not how time dilation works! Bwahaha!”