[quote]ZJStrope wrote:
[quote]usmccds423 wrote:
[quote]ZJStrope wrote:
[quote]usmccds423 wrote:
[quote]ZJStrope wrote:
Making abortion illegal won’t stop abortion from happening. [/quote]
Making the killing of another person murder hasn’t stopped that either. [/quote]
Yeah, I wrote the hastily. I should expand.
Whether something is illegal or not has little to no impact on someone’s decision to do something that has no impact on anyone else but themselves. By making it illegal, you force these people to search out for backyard doctors, fall down stairs, have boyfriends punch them in the stomach, essentially risk their life, to get what they want.
[/quote]
In all seriousness why does that matter? People go outside the law all the time, I don’t think that simple fact should be considered when creating laws.
I also tend to disagree. I want a Camaro SS, but I can’t afford one. Grand theft auto is still illegal, as far as I know, so I don’t have one.
I also think if a woman was charged with murder for using a coat hanger as an abortion tool less women would do it. Same goes for men and stairs and punching.
[/quote]
Your line of reasoning doesn’t fit since your scenario of stealing a car harms someone else.
In this scenario, if someone fundamentally believes that they own their embryo/fetus/whatever you want to refer to it as, and it’s their body, a law will have little to no impact on how they treat themselves.
How would anyone even know that the woman had an abortion? How would you enforce such a law? Who would turn the person in?
If abortion is illegal, maybe masturbation should be illegal? What about visectomies? How about tubal ligations? Birth control?
Laws shold not invade on individual rights which have no impact or is no business to anyone outside of oneself.[/quote]
Abortion harms someone else. Not only does it harm them, it kills them.
None of these:
masturbation
visectomies
tubal ligations
Birth control
Hurts anyone else.