[quote]Teledin wrote:
[quote]orion wrote:
Well, what you seem to want is “36 stratagems”.
I would warn you though, unlike other books you mentioned, na, not quite true but still, anyway, to get to the point, with this one you need to put in the work.
Meaning, active participation is nice reading any book, but if you do not bother, dont bother with this one.
Also, if you do not reread the “Art of War” every three years or so, whats the point anyway.
Also, Hagakure … and Machiavellis contribution to the history of ideas is misunderstood IMO and I would not trust anyone who thinks name dropping Machiavelli is a selling point.
Not because Machiavelli was not right, somewhat, but because he was a bloody amateur compared to Asian authors because the idea that he sought to overcome was never in their heads. They immediately cut to the bone, whereas he is all giddy that he dares to question a catholic morality.
[/quote]
I hear ya. I personally feel the same way, especially currently reading Thick Face, Black Heart. The Machiavelli book, although an amusing read, left me scratching my head at times as I really couldn’t juxtapose many characteristics of a “Machiavellian” with those of the leaders I am privy to. (my boss and the corporate managers, modern political leaders, etc). I think the examples used in that book were more common to the exceptions not the rules. Whereas I can see the majority of characteristic mentioned in Thick Face, Black Heart in the same said leaders.
I definitely am planning to re-read Sun Tzu very soon as I don’t think I quite grasped some of the deeper points from the first read.
I’ll definitely highly consider 36 Stratagems!
[/quote]
Machiavelli, for you, is irrelevant.
The point he made was that there is no catholic morality, the keyword being catholic, as in, all encompassing, including all men, all situations, all actions.
Since you grew up in a culture that does not blindly follow this view, for better or worse, this cannot possibly be a revelation to you.
My point was, if you want to go over to the dark side, or at least want to know what it is all about, read people who never had to overcome the idea that there is one catholic morality.
They spend no time justifying, they immediately get to the nuts and bolts of how to fuck other people over.
Also, if you really want to learn about human nature, which is kind of the topic here, I would look into theology, I kid you not. It needs some work to apply it to todays circumstances, but if you want to learn what human beings are all about you want to learn from people who thought that their immortal soul was in danger unless they found the right answers.