[quote]twojarslave wrote:
[quote]Powerpuff wrote:
What you said about many intellectually gifted kids who aren’t thriving because they lack some of the qualities/traits that bring life success really resonates. One of the smartest kids from my high school got caught up in alcohol/ drug addiction and other negative influences that really sidetracked his life. It was particularly sad because he had so much potential.
[/quote]
This is probably little more than semantic quibbling, but the young man you speak of has not lost any of his potential. He’s merely sidetracked with an unproductive lifestyle. I didn’t bloom until my 30’s (but I had a helluva good time in my 20’s :).
This topic is of great interest to both of us, so I will regale you with another anecdote about gifted children. Take what you will out of it, as it is simply a single anecdote about one very gifted person.
I may have been sharp as a child, but my cousin, same age as me (now 34) is literally a genius. He was also fortunate enough to have been born into life of privilege, with both parents being practicing physicians. He excelled in academics and was a talented flutist. He stayed out of trouble and did what he was supposed to as a student, exceeding all expectations. He went on to gain degrees in electrical engineering, a masters in mathematics and a doctorate in statistics and probability.
He also was, and remains to this day, a great big pussy. I love him like a brother, but that is an inescapable truth about my cousin. He is not an independent adult, currently relying on his wealthy parents’ generosity for support. He has struggled with depression and the day-to-day rigors of life as an adult. He has not had a meaningful intimate relationship of any kind. Simply stated, he hasn’t hacked it at the basics of life and love as an adult and, at age 34 with many advanced degrees, remains unemployed and entirely dependent on his parents.
He has always been very physically weak and has never embraced any physical activity other than an occasional bicycle ride. He has no significant handicaps other than being a very skinny man with some allergies.
As much as I love both my cousin and his parents, I firmly believe that his lack of physical development is a root cause of his struggles as an adult. Now, I can’t pretend to be able to get into the mind of a depressed genius, but you don’t need to be a brilliant psychologist to arrive at this conclusion.
This anecdote dovetails with the point I made about the importance of failure for development. There was nothing that academia could throw at my cousin that was remotely challenging until he got to the point where he was dabbling in pure mathematics, meaning inventing NEW MATH (WTF?). The one arena where he could have both faced and overcame significant challenges in life - physical activity - was not a point of emphasis for him AT ALL. It was simply not a priority for him or his parents. It still is not.
Untapped potential, indeed.
I’m doing my best to convince him to spend a few weeks in Maine to train with me. The seed is planted, we’ll see if anything sprouts.
Again, best of luck to you. Don’t let those little geniuses of yours settle for merely getting good grades. You may as well congratulate a cow for eating grass.[/quote]
Thanks. Yes, it’s a huge interest for me. I keep coming back to this idea of resilience. It’s just key. Thanks for taking the time to tell that story. Awesome non example or cautionary tale. Someone with tremendous intellectual ability who has experienced great academic success. BUT when you look at social relationships and intimacy, emotional health and happiness, financial independence and career, physical health, pretty much any other measure - you’ve got some serious deficits going on.
Some great wisdom there about the dangers of enabling, sheltering and protecting kids. Most of us would really like to see our kids thrive across areas, right? Strength and competency across the board - social, emotional, intellectual, physical, spiritual… How ever you want to break it down. Not that bad stuff won’t happen, but that they’ll be able to cope well.
I think Derek has called this “winning at life.”