[quote]Oleena wrote:
sbmart2 wrote:
Oleena wrote:
Hope you don’t mind the science lesson invasion on your post. Actually, people (or their parents)have to pay all sorts of money to sit and listen to me say what you just got for free, so consider it a gift!!!
Thank you. Okay, so I have a question relating to your advice against using this method in the gym on, say, an every other week basis for maybe two to three different exercises. In the one time that I did it, I was able to bench press 5lbs more after 7 minutes than I’d been capable of before holding the 2x1RM over my head for 10 seconds. That seems like a pretty decent improvement for less than 10 minutes. Now I understand that I wasn’t actually stronger; I hadn’t grown more muscle fibers in that span of time. However, since I was lifting 5lbs more than before, wouldn’t that be more effective at making me grow more muscle fibers in the long run than just maxing out at 5lbs less?
PS I don’t consider it a workout, just something to try on the same day when you’re maxing out.
You are right. Keep doing what you’re doing!!!
I am one of those people who seek information from people who are stronger and have been at this longer, but I have to remember that not everyone is on T-Nation for the same reason as myself.
Good luck in your strength goals.
I’m guessing that was straight-up sarcasm, in which case I think you might have misinterpretted my intention in that previous post. I was literally asking you to explain further what you have previously said. I like being proven wrong on topics, and especially by those who know more than me. However, I like being thoroughly proven wrong. This is helpful because then when I go to explain it to other people, I have all of the arguments nicely stacked up in my head. I’m not a student who asks a question, gets a basic answer, and is satisfied. I like knowing everything I can about the right answer.
So here’s a more straight-forward question to which I hope you respond seriously because I respect your knowledge: how often should one who has been training for less than 6 months max out on deadlift, squat, or bench press if they are strength training 4-5 days a week using between 5-8 reps for each lift?
[/quote]
I think asking questions and learning more is great. But what is important to understand is that if you are new in an area, you don’t know enough to make a good solid argument to prove wrong. I still find myself in this category with lifting. So what I try to do is find people who are currently succeeding in powerlifting and then I soak up any and all information that they are giving me. If, later down the road, I have made it to a level past theirs, then maybe we can have a conversation about methodology. But for now, what they say goes, even if I’ve read something new and cool in a magazine or book. Don’t get me wrong, I ask a lot of questions but I try to phrase it in a way where it isn’t asking them to give me solid proof that they are right and I am wrong. This can come off arrogant and turns people off from trying to help (this may explain my past post).
If you are open to learning and respect people’s advice, there is a lot you can learn from participating in the forums on this site. There are all sorts of amazing women on here who I admire because they have shown the confidence and determination to train hard and test themselves in competition. I am always glad for any time they take to help me out! When I started seriously strength training, I was having trouble knowing whether I was deadlifting correctly so Court had me submit a video and helped me clean up my form. MMgalb has let me start training with her. So I owe a lot to the women on this forum. Okay I will stop turning this into a sap fest.
As for your question about maxing out, both Dianab and Court already gave better advice than I could. Basically don’t worry about maxing out. It is really good if you want to use it to mark progress at the beginning and end of a program. I’m about to test my Maxes after finishing a 4 month program. The other time you worry about maxing out is during a competition!