[quote]rrjc5488 wrote:
AceQHounddog wrote:
Until you get a job that requires you do have to take decisive action with only a split-second to make that decision and act to save yourself or someone else, and then have that action reviewed and critqued for months by people who will never be in that situation, then you have no idea what you are talking about and are talking out of your ass.
You dont need to be a cop to be put in a defensive situation where you have to judge what to do within a split second.
First off: Driving. Being put in defensive situations happens all the time. I was almost pushed into oncoming traffic by a bus today because he didnt look in his blind spot and he decided to switch lanes. I had about a second to brake really fucking hard, or swerve into oncoming traffic, or have a bus drive into me.
Secondly: If I see anyone raping my girlfriend/beating up my little brother/or doing either to any random person, for that matter. And I step in and beat the fuck out of the person assaulting the innocent person, I’m doing it in self defense. I’m pretty sure I’ll be charged with assault myself, but a judge would throw it out since it was in “self defense” or at least in the well being of another.
Either way, none of this still changes the fact that the kid was unnecessarily struck (since, apparently, he wasn’t beaten.) And then fell to the ground, and wasn’t given medical treatment nearly as fast as it should have been given.
I agree with jsbrook. The kid was under the cops’ supervision, and was obviously their responsibility. Whether they beat him or not, he still died in their hands.
vroom wrote:
I’d suggest that if the police weren’t so busy abusing their authority that less people would resent them for it.
I agree here too. I’ve seen a bunch of cops be dicks for no reason at all. I’ve driven behind cops that will be approaching a red light, turn their sirens on so they can drive thru, then turn them off halfway down the block.
My friends drink (which is obviously illeagle since they’re underage) but they’ve been hit (not necessarily beaten) but have had completely unnecessary force imposed on them for no reason at all.
Alot (not all) are on a huge power trip and need to get the fuck off.[/quote]
Wow, first I said DECISIVE, not defensive. Fascinating scenarios, though.
I think the term “Obviously” is a little strong here. To say because the kid was in their custody that it was obviously the cops’ fault is moronic, unless you have personal knowledge of what occurred besides what was on the tape. Again, not defending them and they should pay if they were wrong, but no one here can tell based solely on that video.
A cop going through a red light with lights/siren only to shut down half a block later is very commonplace. If you get a call requiring a a rapid response, you use the authority given you to get there in a timely manner (As you would want if you were the one calling the cops). But often the call is changed or handled by other officers before you get there, you shut down and continue in a normal manner. That is done for the safety of the public. Was this the case when you saw it? Who knows, but to automatically assume it was an abuse of authority is just ignorant.
Lastly, the video was llike six minutes long. How fast does an ambulance arrive where you live? That’s pretty quick for an emergency medical response.