[quote]jbpick86 wrote:
[quote]Sentoguy wrote:
[quote]cycobushmaster wrote:
[quote]Sentoguy wrote:
If you are completely dominating someone while rolling then IMO, yes you should allow them to have some success sometimes and maybe work on your defensive game. So yes, let them pass your guard (make them work for it a little of course) and then let them try to impose their top game while you work on your sub defenses and escapes. Remember that you should both be there to make each other better and build each other up, not demoralize/conquer each other.
.[/quote]
i strongly disagree with this… by doing this, you’re teaching them that what they’re doing works. it doesn’t work, and they need to be a)taught proper technique and b)understand that it doesn’t work.
rolling/sparring and drilling are 2 different things. drilling is working through a technique with varying levels of resistance. but sparring should be reserved for focused technique, at the very least…[/quote]
Perhaps I wasn’t completely clear about what I meant.
Let’s say I have someone in my guard who I am much better than or just sweeping or submitting at will. What good does it really do either of us if I just continue to tool on them other than to boost my ego and crush their spirit?
I’m not suggesting that you just let them pass via incorrect technique; what I’m saying is to let them have some success passing but make them do it right and make them work for it. We’re talking about white belts here; they’re practically babies. If they know any effective passes, it’s probably only one, maybe two, they aren’t going to likely be great at executing or setting them up, and really they shouldn’t be expected to (keep in mind I’m talking about being good enough to pull them off against someone who is better than them). And clearly, from the OP’s post, these people were struggling with correctly executing the techniques during rolling.
Or, you just start from a position or disadvantage right from the get go (give them side control, mount, north south, back control, etc…) do they get to work on their offense while you work on your defense.
You should be able to turn your intensity dial up or down accordingly so that both people are being challenged, neither is being cheated or conquered.[/quote]
While I like the idea about starting form a disadvantageous position or “calling a shot”, do you really think that most white belts, even if they are superior to their sparring partner, have a complete enough grasp on the techniques to dial it back and allow their partner to pass without reinforcing a bad technique?? [/quote]
Depends on the school and the white belt, but in most cases probably no, they don’t.
One could choose not to use a counter or technical defense to a pass though. That way the other student’s technique still has to be correct to pass, but he’s not being shut down. Either that or like I said, just keep going for the same sweep or submission and it should continue to get more and more challenging as they start to get better at defending it which will force you to work on your submission set-ups, extensions, and combinations.