[quote]angry chicken wrote:
[quote]HoustonGuy wrote:
[quote]angry chicken wrote:
A bunch of really awesome points, largely ignored.
[/quote]
With all due respect, while rig work is certainly dangerous, requires a hairy set of nuts and unfortunately lends itself to deadly accidents, you work in a mechanically controlled environment with back up safety equipment, protocol and procedures. Unless you contract to BP, the only real room for error ending in tragedy is human error on the part of operators and inspectors who absolutely should be held accountable if negligence is discovered. The continuity of machinery and benchmark indicators of maintenance generally remain static.
Police are involved in situations made volatile by the unpredictability of human nature, often fanned by flames of fear, anger, guilt, drug abuse et cetera. When quantifying the dangers of job A vs. job B, it’s only fair to qualify the ramifications of each danger as well. Scaling would indeed require imaginative subjectivity but you can’t honestly say police aren’t faced with highly dangerous and, even worse, unpredictable scenarios on a regular basis that not only put them but also innocent people on the line; innocent people they risk their own lives to protect.
A system engineered by very brilliant minds and maintained to spec is another ballgame altogether.[/quote]
I didn’t make the ranking, that’s why I posted those links (more than one). According to the smarter people than you or I MY career is more dangerous than cops. They are BOTH dangerous jobs. And FYI, I’m not on nice new drilling rigs, I’m on 50 year old production platforms with years of “southern engineering” and multiple code violations. I’ve been tasked to bring it up to code without interrupting production. That means doing it hot in class 1, div 1 locations. Sometimes in 40 mph wind. If you think that’s easy, simple, controlled or well engineered, you are mistaken, my friend. But you’re missing my point.
My job is dangerous and has potential deadly consequences to priceless things like human life and the environment. If I DROP A PIECE OF TRASH, I can go to jail. That’s how strict the enforcement is. No one WANT’S to drop trash. No one WANT’S to cause an oil spill. Just like most cops don’t WANT to shoot a guy reaching for his wallet.
But when it happens, when the the unfortunate RESULT is a loss of life (just like when the unfortunate RESULT has damaged the environment REGARDLESS OF INTENTION) THEY have NO consequence.
I personally believe that human life is more valuable than the environment. There are FAR MORE people “accidentally killed” by cops than there are oil spills, but far more people lose their jobs for oil spill than COPS lose their jobs for killing innocent people.
I think there should be a higher standard for cops. They wear body armor and carry weapons. I don’t think they should be allowed to draw down on people because of an UNKNOWN danger. I think they should be allowed to bring deadly force into play ONLY when deadly force is brought against them - kinda like the rules of engagement our military boys have to abide by in KNOWN COMBAT ZONES. A lot less innocent people would die.
Yes, more cops would probable die as well, and that’s a risk they will KNOWINGLY accept when they decide to become police officers. But the lives of the citizens they SERVE and are charged to PROTECT is worth it.[/quote]
Southern Engineering is certainly a friendly term, and probably a better one. I like that. Just keep in mind the big boys are usually hiring… you’d more than likely be a shoe in on your own now though.
Regardless of who made the point, I’m addressing your addition to the conversation. A “smart” pollster will allow room for subjective gray area.
The point I’m making is that regardless of work conditions on a rig which are tough, sweaty and take some hairy nuts, you are working with a grain of continuity (as in wood grain; a flow and not a tiny spec). Known dangers with known outcomes. While I’m sure you may not always know exactly where a charge is grounded or a screw is located until you have eyes on it, you have the luxury of knowing what you are looking for time and again.
A cop doesn’t. The greater element of surprise begets a different set of rules of engagement. Speaking of rules of engagement, ask a soldier what he thinks about the shoot first policy. A real one who has actually seen combat. There is no right answer really, but the people charged with serving and protecting ought to have enough autonomy to do so. The error shouldn’t result in failed missions, aborted positions and compromised goals.
A cop does volunteer for the job, that doesn’t mean he volunteers for suicide and shouldn’t be expected to escape death by luck and then start protecting himself.
Greenpeace bullshit lobbyists certainly shouldn’t be setting precedents for police operations vicariously through an indirectly, conversationally attached subjective danger ranking. It’s a shame what they’ve done to the oil industry frankly.
- I’m not avoiding you either. I got your spring break message but had plans in place and forgot about it. Crystal beach can be fun, the additional 4 hrs to S. Padre would be worth it next time though. SP spring break is absolutely insane. MTV, Jerry Springer and countless other shows have been broadcasting their TV “bashes” there for years. It’s fun year round spring break is a fucking circus of sex, drugs and rock and roll by twenty somethings from Texas and flown in from around the US at large. Unfortunately the quick trip to mexico is now basically shut down thanks to the Zetas simultaneously providing the fun and scaring people from it.