[quote]ReignIB wrote:
[quote]florelius wrote:
[quote]ReignIB wrote:
[quote]florelius wrote:
[quote]ReignIB wrote:
[quote]florelius wrote:
benos:
I am going to bed so I cant adress your entire post right now, but I can touch on some of the things
you mentioned.
- concerns about nazi involment: Even though I understand the mayority of the protesters to be left of center
and not nazi scum bags …
[/quote]
Nazis were/are leftist in nature. Their racist/antisemitic doctrine is what typically gets them a “right wing” placement, but their whole anti-big business, anti-individualism, dictatorship “for the good of the nation” etc etc agenda puts them right next to the communists, the only significant difference being their views on private property, although not that different after all:
“Private property” as conceived under liberalistic economic order was a reversal of the true concept of property. This “private proprerty” represented the right of the individual to manage and to speculate with inherited or acquired property as he pleased, without regard to the general interests…German socialism had to overcome this “private”, that is, unrestrained and irresponsible view of property. All property is common property. The owner is bound by the people and the Reich to the responsible management of his goods. His legal position is only justified when he satisfies this responsibility to the community.
(Ernst Huber, Nazi party spokesman; National Socialism, prepared by Raymond E. Murphy, et al; quoting Huber, Verfassungsrecht des grossdeutschen Reiches (Hamburg, 1939))
[/quote]
…
But again this is not the part of their ideology that is whats define them, or earn them the scumbag badge :P…[/quote]
but it is.
somehow it is that same ideology of forced social equality and class warfare (with a racist twist in nazi’s case) that has produced some of the most bloodthirsty regimes in history.
[/quote]
… Maybe thats why I dont recognize the nazi`s as typically socialist, because they stand on the opposit side on most issues from us( norwegian socialists ).
[/quote]
but that’s what they are - socialists, whether you “recognize” it or not.
here’s a good read if you’re interested:
Okay I can agree that they in economcial matters they are center-left, but to say like this. All national-socialist are socialists, but not all socialists are national-socialist.
Basickly saying that most socialist you will encounter( me included ) arent nazis.
And to be stating the obvious: The nazi horror wherent the establishment of a welfare state in germany, but rather the fact that they killed of 6million jews, waged war against almost the entire world and that they established a totalitarian tyranny. If you remove all the rectionary shit from their ideology, you are left with a vague socialdemocratic plattform.