[quote]2-SCOOPS wrote:
well looks like the door for discussion in open
lol, i don’t take offense to your conflicting advice. however i will say that just doing a few of the little things i’ve mentioned has helped increase my squat 200+lbs in less than 2 years and has now put me at over a 3xbw raw squat at almost a bw of 200lbs. my training partner has visited rip’s gym several times and has not been impressed by the strength of anyone at anytime at rip’s gym, after reading your post he says that now makes sense why he saw so many shitty squats at his gym. most of my spare time is spent watching lifting videos haha and i’ve seen what good squatters do and have added what they do into what i do and has helped my squatting significiantly. good squatters will almost arch out of the hole, almost like they are driving their neck/head back into the bar, if you do this, your hips will automatically follow. but it doesn’t make sense to start with the hips if your hips will automatically come through if you keep upright and lead with your head. you can clearly see this in many squat vids(of good squatters) and if i find some time i will post one on my log since it seems i’m already taking some of ashy’s log space with a little debate.
And to ashy, I apoligize for taking up space, but find what you like to do and what works for you, i would take information from everywhere and sift out what you like and think works for you.[/quote]
Just a few points. Rip’s whole deal is he gets people started. He takes them from… 135 or less on squat up to 300+. He doesn’t train powerlifters, so I wouldn’t expect him to have a ton of really strong squatters. And he does not teach a powerlifting squat anyways - it’s a medium stance low bar squat. It is not designed to move maximum weight - it’s supposed to be a balanced squat that includes as many muscles as it can (and I’m assuming Adam is not trying to do a p-lifting squat either, just use the squat to get bigger/stronger).
Personally, I find the hip drive aspect gives me a ton more consistency. I USED to squat the style you’re talking about - trying to keep as upright as humanly possible. But at higher weights, I would often lose balance backwards and my squat in general just felt weird as if I could never find the proper groove. With the style Rip advocates, I’ve fixed that and each squat feels the same. Note that Rip actually has used the OPPOSITE CUE (it’s on DVD) for a guy who had a tendency to cave his chest. In that case, he told him to drive the chest up and it fixed his problem.
Everybody is different. If somebody naturally tends to descend forward too much, a hard arch out of the bottom will put the weight over the foot in a better place. What I’m seeing on Adam’s video is he’s trying to stay too upright and it makes him tentative on the descent. From what I understand, the reason he leans forward right out of the hole is that the “leaned forward” position is the most natural position for him at the bottom due to his individual limb lengths. Staying more upright would cause him to fall backward.
Also, note that Wendler actually teaches hip drive in the squat (EFS Boston seminar on Youtube) and Matt Kroc exhibits what looks like the same style (Youtube for Kroczaleski squat and look for the 400 pounds for 10).
So it’s not just Rip’s gym, but some damn strong powerlifters are on board with the idea as well.
In essence, I just think that everybody will be different, and that for Adam’s particular case, a lot of the weirdness in the squat would be fixed by using hip drive instead of chest drive. Note again that I used to exhibit this same pattern - tentative descent and hips shoot up faster than chest.
Ironically I fixed it by driving my hips instead of trying to stay so damn upright.
Edit: one more thing - like I said in my first long post about the squat, the wider your stance the more upright you will be (think of how upright your torso is in a conventional dead vs a sumo dead). So what you’re saying probably makes a lot of sense for a really wide stance powerlifting squat as it might be easier to fall forward. I never tried it, so I’m not going to pretend to be a coach, but it’s certainly true that your torso will be more upright than a medium or narrow stance squat. That might make chest drive a better cue.